Arguments
Philosophy’s structured arguments, from the cosmological argument to the Chinese room: find one by name or browse by question, subject, thinker, tradition or letter.
On this page
441 structured arguments. Each sets out the argument’s steps, the main objections and the replies, with the questions, thinkers and traditions it belongs to.
Find or filter the arguments
Matching arguments
23 arguments for letter C.
-
Camus's argument that the absurd does not justify suicide
Albert Camus's argument in The Myth of Sisyphus that the clash between our demand for meaning and a silent world calls neither for suicide nor for hope, but for lucid revolt.
-
Carlson's argument for scientific cognitivism
Allen Carlson's argument, from an analogy with the appreciation of art, that appropriate aesthetic appreciation of nature requires knowledge supplied by the natural sciences (his 'natural environmental model').
-
Carroll's common reason argument
Noël Carroll's argument for moderate moralism: sometimes the very feature that makes a work morally flawed, such as an immoral perspective that blocks the response the work seeks, also makes it aesthetically flawed.
-
Carroll's regress
The regress in Lewis Carroll's dialogue 'What the Tortoise Said to Achilles', in which every attempt to state the link between premises and conclusion as a further premise creates a new gap.
-
Cartesian circle
The objection that Descartes argues in a circle in the Meditations, using clear and distinct perception to prove that God exists and then appealing to God to guarantee that clear and distinct perception is true.
-
Cārvāka critique of inference
The Cārvāka (Lokāyata) argument, known mainly from opponents' and doxographers' reports, that inference is not an independent means of knowledge because the universal pervasion (vyāpti) it needs cannot be known by perception, inference, testimony or comparison; older reports show the school accepting everyday, perception-based inference.
-
Causal exclusion argument
The argument, refined by Jaegwon Kim, that if every physical effect has a sufficient physical cause, mental properties distinct from physical ones are left with no causal work to do. It is the main challenge to non-reductive physicalism.
-
Causal inefficacy objection
The objection that an individual's purchase or abstention makes no difference to large systems of production, so cannot be required on consequentialist grounds; replies appeal to expected consequences, free-riding and non-causal principles.
-
Child-at-the-well argument
Mencius's argument (Mengzi 2A6) that anyone who suddenly saw a child about to fall into a well would feel alarm and compassion without ulterior motive, showing an innate sprout of benevolence.
-
Chinese nation argument
Block's thought experiment in which the population of China, passing messages partly by satellite and controlling an artificial body, reproduces the functional organisation of a brain; it seems implausible that the whole system would feel anything.
-
Chinese room argument
John Searle's 1980 thought experiment and argument that running a program cannot by itself produce understanding, because programs are purely syntactic and syntax is not sufficient for semantics.
-
Chrysippus's cylinder argument
Chrysippus's argument, known through Cicero's De Fato 39-43 and Gellius's Attic Nights 7.2, that although everything happens by fate through antecedent causes, assent and action are up to us, because external causes only start the motion while the agent's own nature, like a pushed cylinder's shape, determines it.
-
Clifford's ethics-of-belief argument
W. K. Clifford's argument in "The Ethics of Belief" (1877) that, because beliefs guide action, are held in common and shape the believer's and society's habits of inquiry, it is morally wrong for anyone to believe anything on insufficient evidence.
-
The closure argument for scepticism
The argument that we are not justified in ordinary beliefs about the external world because, by the closure principle, such justification would also justify rejecting sceptical hypotheses, which we cannot do.
-
Collingridge dilemma
David Collingridge's problem for governing new technologies: early on, a technology can be controlled but its harms cannot be foreseen; by the time the harms are clear, the technology is entrenched and control is costly and slow.
-
Combination problem
The central objection to panpsychism: if the smallest constituents of matter have experiences of their own, how do they combine into the unified consciousness of a human being?
-
Common consent argument
The argument that the widespread belief in God across peoples and ages is itself evidence that God exists; defended in modest evidential form by Thomas Kelly.
-
Communicative theory of punishment
The view that legal punishment is justified as the communication of deserved censure to offenders, aiming at their repentance, reform and reparation.
-
Condorcet jury theorem
Condorcet's 1785 result that if voters are independent and each more likely than not to be right on a yes-or-no question, a majority is more reliable than any one of them and becomes almost certainly right as the group grows; the founding argument of epistemic democracy.
-
The consent argument for political obligation
The argument that citizens are obliged to obey the state because, and to the extent that, they have consented to its authority, expressly or tacitly.
-
Consequence argument
An argument for incompatibilism, widely regarded as the best one: if determinism is true, our acts are consequences of the laws of nature and the remote past, neither of which is up to us, so our acts are not up to us either.
-
Contrary-to-duty paradox
Roderick Chisholm's 1963 puzzle showing that standard deontic logic cannot consistently and independently represent obligations that come into force once another obligation has been violated.
-
Curry's paradox
A family of paradoxes in which a sentence or set says, in effect, 'if this is true, then anything', and a few plausible rules then prove any claim whatever, without any use of negation.