Arguments
Philosophy’s structured arguments, from the cosmological argument to the Chinese room: find one by name or browse by question, subject, thinker, tradition or letter.
On this page
441 structured arguments. Each sets out the argument’s steps, the main objections and the replies, with the questions, thinkers and traditions it belongs to.
Find or filter the arguments
Matching arguments
20 arguments for letter F.
-
Fackenheim's argument for the 614th commandment
Emil Fackenheim's argument, first stated in 1967, that since no explanation of Auschwitz is adequate, the only authentic response is existential: Jews are forbidden to hand Hitler a posthumous victory, a commanding imperative he called the 614th commandment.
-
Fairness argument against doping
The argument that performance-enhancing drugs should be banned because they give users an unfair advantage; opponents reply that natural and financial inequalities already tilt the field and that permitting enhancement for all could level it.
-
Fake barn case
The thought experiment, first given by Carl Ginet and published by Alvin Goldman in 1976, in which a driver truly and justifiably believes he sees a barn in a district full of barn façades, yet seems not to know it.
-
Fakhr al-Dīn al-Rāzī's argument that conceptions are not acquired
Fakhr al-Din al-Razi's argument, using a version of Meno's paradox and a four-way division, that no conception (taṣawwur) of a thing is gained by deliberate inquiry, so that definitions only analyse the meanings of names.
-
Feuerbach's argument that God is the objectified human essence
Ludwig Feuerbach's reasoning in The Essence of Christianity (1841) that the divine predicates are human predicates freed from individual limits, so that God is the essence of the human species made objective and revered as another being, and theology is at bottom anthropology.
-
Fine-tuning argument
The argument that the sensitivity of life to the values of physical constants, laws and initial conditions is evidence for a designer; a modern version of the teleological argument, rivalled by multiverse explanations.
-
Fission problem
The puzzle about personal identity raised by imagining a person whose brain hemispheres are transplanted into two bodies: each resulting person seems to have equal claim to be the original, yet the original cannot be both.
-
Fitch's paradox of knowability
A short proof that if every truth is knowable then every truth is known; it threatens anti-realist theories that tie truth to the possibility of knowledge.
-
Flying man argument
Ibn Sina's thought experiment of a human being created fully formed in the air, cut off from all sensation, who would still grasp that he exists without grasping that he has a body.
-
Food immoralism
The view, defended by Shen-yi Liao and Aaron Meskin, that a moral defect in a food's history can sometimes make that food aesthetically better precisely because of the defect.
-
Frame problem
Originally the problem in logic-based AI of representing the effects of actions without listing everything they leave unchanged; in philosophy, the wider problem of how a thinker determines what is relevant when updating beliefs.
-
Frankfurt cases
Thought experiments, introduced by Harry Frankfurt in 1969, in which an agent seems morally responsible for an action although a hidden intervener would have ensured that she could not have done otherwise.
-
Free will defence
Alvin Plantinga's argument that God and evil are logically compatible, because God may have had to permit evil in order to create creatures with morally significant freedom.
-
Fregean argument for mathematical platonism
The argument that, because mathematical singular terms purport to refer and most accepted theorems are true, mathematical objects exist; the main template for arguing for object realism in mathematics.
-
Frege–Geach problem
The challenge, pressed by Peter Geach after Frege, that non-cognitivist theories of moral language cannot explain the meaning of moral sentences in embedded contexts or the validity of ordinary moral arguments.
-
Fricker's argument that testimonial injustice wrongs a speaker as a knower
Miranda Fricker's argument that when identity prejudice deflates the credibility a hearer gives a speaker, the speaker suffers a distinctively epistemic wrong: denial of their standing as a knower, over and above any practical harm.
-
Friedman's argument against corporate social responsibility
Milton Friedman's 1970 case that managers, as agents of the shareholders who own the firm, should maximise shareholder wealth rather than spend corporate resources on social goals.
-
Frye's birdcage argument
Marilyn Frye's argument in 'Oppression' (The Politics of Reality, 1983) that oppression is a network of barriers that are each small and seemingly harmless when examined one at a time, like the wires of a birdcage, but together confine a group.
-
Fungibility problem (love)
The objection that if love is justified by the beloved's valuable properties, anyone with the same or better properties would serve as well, making beloveds replaceable and 'trading up' rational.
-
Future contingents
Statements about future events that are neither impossible nor inevitable, such as 'there will be a sea battle tomorrow', and the problem of whether, and how, they are true or false now.