Coordinates of Thought: philosophy questions, debates and reading groups from every tradition
A home for philosophy
Find where you stand.
Learn philosophy from the beginning, look up 131 big questions and 1,118 thinkers, find a good book, and talk it over. Free to read; every tradition is welcome.
New to philosophy? Begin hereLook up a word in the Philosophy Glossary
Explore
- Learn70 guides and a glossary of 1,564 terms
- The Coordinates131 big questions and the positions
- Thinkers1,118 profiles, A–Z and by tradition
- Traditions16 traditions and 76 schools
- Books1,233 books, 125 reading paths
- AtlasPlaces, timeline, journeys of ideas
- JournalEssays and short guides
- Conversations1,788 questions, debates and more
Latest conversations
Reading is free. Write first: you join free or sign in when you post.
-
Al-Shāfiʿī said that whoever uses istiḥsān has made himself a lawgiver. Was he right to distrust a judge’s sense of fairness?
In the classical schools of Islamic law there was a long argument about istiḥsān, usually translated "juristic preference": departing from the result that strict analogy would give, because another ruling seems more fitting, more just, or more in the public interest. The…
Started by Khalid Mahmood Awan (illustrative reader, by the editors)Reply first (no replies yet) -
Śaiva Siddhānta says the freed soul enjoys Śiva but never becomes Śiva. Why would a religion refuse union?
I read Śaiva Siddhānta on my own, in Tamil, when my children are asleep. It is the philosophy of the Tamil Śaiva tradition, systematised in the thirteenth century by Meykaṇṭār in a short text of twelve sūtras, the Civañāṉapōtam. It teaches three…
Started by Thamarai Raman (illustrative reader, by the editors)2 replies -
Question of the day: what really follows from “if this, then that”?
Today's question comes from the card on propositional logic: what follows from "if this, then that"? Some things are agreed. From "if it rains, the match is cancelled" and "it rains", it follows that the match is cancelled (modus ponens). From the…
Started by The Editors4 replies -
A shop undercharges you and you notice only at home. Do you have to go back?
An everyday case. You get home from a shop and, unpacking, notice that the cashier rang up the expensive item at the price of a cheaper one. You've saved a fair amount. The shop is twenty minutes away. Nobody will ever know.…
Started by The Editors1 reply -
French ‘travail’ is said to come from a torture device, the tripalium. Does the etymology tell us anything about work?
Every French schoolchild learns, at some point, that travail comes from the Latin tripalium, an instrument of torture made of three stakes. The story is repeated in self-help books, union speeches and dinner parties: our very word for work remembers that work…
Started by Claire Dubois (illustrative reader, by the editors)2 replies Question of the day
What follows from "if this, then that"?4.1.1 Propositional Logic · All 131 questions
-
A village godman predicted good rain three years running. How many hits before it stops being luck?
On weekends our rationalist association visits villages in Dakshina Kannada where someone claims special powers. Usually we show the trick: the "holy ash" from an empty hand, the coconut that bursts into flame. Those are easy. This year we met something harder.…
Started by Arvind Poojary (illustrative reader, by the editors)Reply first (no replies yet) -
A man in my prison class asks whether God can forgive him if the family he harmed never will. What do the traditions say?
Last week in our reading class a man asked the question that has stayed with me since. He has found faith in prison. He prays and believes God has forgiven him for what he did. But the family of the man he…
Started by Brian Otieno Ouma (illustrative reader, by the editors)1 reply -
At the bedside, should I tell someone their illness is a test from God?
Visiting the sick is a duty in my community, and I have sat by many hospital beds in Bradford. Again and again I hear the same sentence, from relatives, from visitors, sometimes from my own mouth: "This is a test from Allah."…
Started by Bilal Rashid (illustrative reader, by the editors)1 reply -
Absorbed in a hard exam, I forgot myself for an hour. Was I still aware of myself in some background way?
Last week I sat a three-hour statistics exam. For the middle hour I was completely absorbed. I don't remember thinking "I" once. Then someone dropped a pencil case and suddenly I was back: aware of my sore neck, my nerves, myself. My…
Started by Elif Yıldız (illustrative reader, by the editors)2 replies -
Reading group: Anscombe’s Intention, sections 1–26, over two weeks
G. E. M. Anscombe's Intention (1957) is under a hundred pages and has been called the most important treatment of action since Aristotle. It is also famously dense. Read slowly, together, it opens up. Anscombe asks what makes an action intentional. Her…
Started by The Editors1 reply -
Kautsa said the Vedic mantras have no meaning, and Yāska answered him. Does a ritual word need to mean anything to work?
In the Nirukta, the ancient Sanskrit work on the meaning of Vedic words, Yāska records an objection by a teacher named Kautsa: the mantras are meaningless. They are fixed in their word order and can't be paraphrased; some ask questions of beings…
Started by Govinda Prasad Upadhyaya (illustrative reader, by the editors)2 replies -
Reading group: Ibn Khaldun on why the sciences thrive in cities and die with them, Muqaddimah chapter six, over three weeks
Today's question asks how science changes. Ibn Khaldun has an answer that none of the modern philosophers in the card quite gives: sciences rise and fall with cities. In the sixth chapter of The Muqaddimah he argues that scientific instruction is a…
Started by Youssef Berrada (illustrative reader, by the editors)2 replies New members this week
- Luc Perrenoud Illustrative Reader · By the EditorsWatchmaker restoring mechanical watches, La Chaux-de-Fondsjoined 3 days ago
- Ramon Dela Cruz Illustrative Reader · By the EditorsShip's cook on container vessels, home in Iloilo between contractsjoined 3 days ago
- Karma Wangmo Illustrative Reader · By the EditorsSecondary-school teacher in Paro; Buddhist ethics and Gross National Happinessjoined 3 days ago
- Yashvijoined 4 days ago
- Carmela Esposito Illustrative Reader · By the EditorsHairdresser with her own salon in the Rione Sanità, Naplesjoined 4 days ago
-
My debaters win with valid arguments built on a bad “if”. Should validity earn any credit at all?
Here's a pattern I see at almost every tournament. A team builds a perfectly valid chain: "If the state funds X, it must fund Y. If it funds Y, it must fund Z. It can't afford Z. Therefore it shouldn't fund X."…
Started by Sam Ellery (illustrative reader, by the editors)2 replies -
Oedipus runs from the oracle and fulfils it by running. Is the play about fate, or about the need to know?
Every year my liceo students read Oedipus the King in Greek, slowly, and every year someone asks the same question by the third week: "So he never had a chance?" The story is well known. An oracle says Oedipus will kill his…
Started by Giulia Ferrante (illustrative reader, by the editors)2 replies -
Reading group: Husserl’s Crisis, §9 on Galileo, the ‘discovering and concealing genius’
My evening reading group in Hong Kong is starting a short text in two weeks, and anyone here is welcome to read alongside us in this thread. The text is §9 of Husserl's last work, The Crisis of European Sciences and Transcendental…
Started by Kenneth Lam Chi-ho (illustrative reader, by the editors)1 reply -
Every catalogue decides what counts as philosophy. Can a classification ever be neutral?
Most of my working day is spent deciding where things go. A manuscript arrives with a title page missing, and I have to decide: is this medicine, astrology, natural philosophy, theology? Each answer sends it to a different shelf, and readers find…
Started by Mona Fathy (illustrative reader, by the editors)1 reply -
Aristotle says chance is a real cause, only an incidental one. Is luck in the world, or only in our ignorance?
Last spring I finished a pair of carved cedar doors for a house that had cancelled the order. They stood in the workshop for weeks. On the afternoon I swept them clean, a man came in looking for a gift for his…
Started by Hicham Ouazzani (illustrative reader, by the editors)Answer first (no replies yet) -
Trusting your gut is a legitimate way of knowing
A motion for the evening. A nurse senses that a patient is about to deteriorate before any number on the monitor changes. A carpenter knows which beam will split. An investor has "a bad feeling" about a deal. Sometimes they are spectacularly…
Started by The Editors4 replies -
In Vietnamese I can’t say “I” without saying who you are to me. Does the language know something about the self?
When I translate Sartre into Vietnamese, the hardest word is not néant. It is je. Vietnamese has a neutral first person, tôi, but in ordinary speech we mostly refer to ourselves with kinship words that depend on the listener. To my mother…
Started by Vũ Quốc Bảo (illustrative reader, by the editors)1 reply -
Reading group: the Therīgāthā, verses of the first Buddhist nuns, a few poems a week for three weeks
The Therīgāthā, the "Verses of the Elder Nuns", is a collection of short poems in the Pāli canon attributed to women who became nuns in the Buddha's time. Scholars often describe it as among the earliest surviving anthologies of women's religious poetry…
Started by Nirmala Jayasekara (illustrative reader, by the editors)2 replies -
The rabbis said study “not for its own sake” leads to study for its own sake. Can a wrong motive grow into a right one?
There is a saying in the Talmud, in tractate Pesachim (50b), that I quote at the start of every new evening class: a person should always occupy himself with Torah and the commandments even not for their own sake, for from "not…
Started by Miriam Adler (illustrative reader, by the editors)2 replies -
Solidarity is owed to workers you will never meet
On the docks, solidarity is not an abstract word. It means you don't cross a picket line, you cover for a mate who's hurt, you refuse unsafe work together. It is built on faces, names and shared risk. But there is an…
Started by Hugo Marchetti (illustrative reader, by the editors)3 replies -
Eriugena divided nature into four, and God appears twice: as what creates and is not created, and as what neither creates nor is created. Is God the beginning and the end in the same sense?
Eriugena's great work, the Periphyseon, written in the 860s, opens by dividing "nature", meaning everything that is and is not, into four: what creates and is not created; what is created and creates; what is created and does not create; what neither…
Started by Siobhán Keane (illustrative reader, by the editors)Reply first (no replies yet) -
From the Book corner: Iris Murdoch’s The Sovereignty of Good, and a kestrel outside the window
Iris Murdoch's The Sovereignty of Good (1970) is three essays, short enough for a weekend, and it is a quiet attack on the picture of moral life that dominated English philosophy when she wrote. On that picture, the moral agent is a…
Started by The Editors2 replies -
Data that no human ever looks at can still violate your privacy
In my job I work with data that, in practice, no person ever reads. Millions of transactions, locations, clicks. Models are trained on it; scores come out. If you asked me whether anyone at my company has looked at a particular customer's…
Started by Nur Aisyah Rahman (illustrative reader, by the editors)3 replies -
The Book of the Wise Philosophers came to Ge’ez from Arabic. When does a translated wisdom book become a people’s own?
In the manuscripts I catalogue around Gondar there is a book that appears again and again: the Book of the Wise Philosophers (Mäṣḥafä fälasfa ṭäbiban). It is a collection of sayings attributed to Socrates, Plato, Aristotle, Diogenes, and many sages whose names…
Started by Dawit Gebremedhin (illustrative reader, by the editors)3 replies -
The Mourides say work is a form of prayer. Is that Weber’s Protestant ethic in another key?
In Senegal the Mouride brotherhood, founded by Cheikh Ahmadou Bamba in the late nineteenth century, is everywhere: in the markets, the transport companies, the diaspora traders on the streets of Europe. Bamba taught a path of devotion in which work done for…
Started by Khady Sène (illustrative reader, by the editors)2 replies -
Aristotle says we become brave by doing brave things. Can you practise courage when nothing real is at stake?
Aristotle's line is famous: we become just by doing just acts, temperate by doing temperate acts, and brave by doing brave acts. Virtue is built like a skill, by practice. For thirty years I coached under-16 rugby, and I told the boys…
Started by Gerrit Venter (illustrative reader, by the editors)Answer first (no replies yet) -
Is it wrong to give to someone begging just so you can stop feeling bad?
An everyday case. You pass the same man asking for change outside the station every morning. Some days you walk past and feel a small, sharp discomfort for the next ten minutes. Some days you give him a coin, and the discomfort…
Started by The Editors3 replies -
Winemakers say a wine “expresses its place”. Can a place have a character, or is terroir a story we drink?
Every winemaker I know talks about terroir: the idea that a wine carries the character of the particular ground, slope and climate it came from. A Burgundy vineyard a few hundred metres from another is said to make recognisably different wine, year…
Started by Bec Doyle (illustrative reader, by the editors)Reply first (no replies yet)