Coordinates of Thought: philosophy questions, debates and reading groups from every tradition
-
How would a Buddhist philosopher state the hard problem, if at all?
David Chalmers' 1995 paper "Facing Up to the Problem of Consciousness" separates the "easy" problems (explaining discrimination, report, attention and so on) from the hard one: why any of this processing is accompanied by experience at all. Buddhist philosophy has a detailed…
Started by Priya Raghavan5 replies -
Breaking a promise can be the right thing to do, but it always leaves something owed
You promised to help a friend move house on Saturday morning. On the way you stop at a road accident and spend the morning helping the injured. Everyone agrees you did the right thing. The motion: even when breaking a promise is…
Started by The Editors4 replies -
Reading group: Hume’s Treatise, “Of the obligation of promises” (3.2.5), in one evening
After today's question, I'd like to read the section of Hume that the whole debate goes back to. It's short, perhaps twelve pages. The Book corner page is here: A Treatise of Human Nature. Hume makes two claims that still divide philosophers.…
Started by Alistair Gow1 reply -
Laozi says light promises earn little trust. Should a careful person promise as little as possible?
For forty years I designed railway signalling, and I learned never to promise a time I didn't control. "The train will arrive at 6:12" is a promise made by a timetable, and the timetable is often a liar. Chapter 63 of the…
Started by Liu Mingqiao2 replies -
When “I’ll come at ten” means sometime after ten, has anyone broken a promise?
Our batik workshop sells to buyers in Yogyakarta and abroad, and I've learned that "I promise it will be ready on Tuesday" means two different things depending on who hears it. In Indonesia we joke about jam karet, "rubber time". If a…
Started by Ratna Wulandari2 replies -
A man in my class promised his daughter he’ll never go back to prison. Should he have promised what he can’t be sure of?
One of the men in my reading class has his release date. On the last family visit his daughter, who is eleven, made him promise he will never come back here. He promised. He told me about it the next week, and…
Started by Brian Otieno Ouma3 replies -
If the future is already there, as some physicists say, what is a promise about?
I build measuring instruments and spend my Sunday afternoons with Kierkegaard, so this thread on promising set off an odd chain of thought. Many physicists read relativity as supporting a "block universe": past, present and future events are all equally real, laid…
Started by Lars Eriksen2 replies -
Can you promise to love someone, if Nietzsche is right that we can promise actions but not feelings?
My cousin is getting married in Kochi next month, and I've been asked to translate the vows into English for the relatives coming from abroad. At "I promise to love you all the days of my life", my pen stopped. Nietzsche, in…
Started by Kavya Menon2 replies -
The guidelines changed and your doctor now advises the opposite. Should you trust her more, or less?
An everyday case. For years, parents in several countries were advised to keep peanuts away from babies to prevent allergy. Then the advice reversed: the evidence suggested that introducing them early, carefully, lowered the risk. A mother who followed the first advice…
Started by The Editors4 replies -
My fish supplier has broken his delivery promise three times. How much should his fourth promise count?
My fish supplier is charming, cheap and has the best snapper in the city. He has also, in the last two months, promised three Friday deliveries by four o'clock and arrived at seven, five and not at all. On Friday nights in…
Started by Joel D'Souza2 replies -
A collective agreement binds every member, including those who voted against it
I'm a union delegate at the port. Last spring we negotiated a new agreement on shifts. It was put to a vote, it passed with sixty-two per cent, and I signed it on behalf of all of us. Some of the thirty-eight…
Started by Hugo Marchetti3 replies -
A government’s public promise of housing creates a right, and courts should enforce it
In the settlement where I've been working, families were told by municipal officials, at a public meeting nearly twenty years ago, that they would be moved into new houses on a named piece of land "within three years". People still have the…
Started by Thandeka Mokoena3 replies -
At twenty-five I promised myself I’d leave industry by thirty-five. I’m thirty-six. Who exactly is bound?
At twenty-five I wrote in a notebook: "By thirty-five I leave industry and do research on things that matter." I was quite serious. I even told my sister, so that someone would hold me to it. I'm thirty-six and still building machine-learning…
Started by Pieter van Dijkhuizen2 replies -
When a patient signs a consent form, what has she done: promised, permitted, or only acknowledged?
I interpret for patients signing consent forms many times a week. Before they sign, I translate the form. Then, very often, the patient asks me a question that shows they think they have just done something quite different from what the form…
Started by Tsion Bekele2 replies -
Finding beauty in a well-executed military operation is a moral failure
After twenty-two years in the army I can say honestly that some military things are beautiful. A company moving through terrain in perfect order. A night exercise where every unit arrives on the minute. Even the plan for an operation can have…
Started by Choi Byeong-hun4 replies -
Was “forty acres and a mule” a promise, and does a broken public promise leave a debt?
My eleventh-graders know the phrase "forty acres and a mule". Almost none of them know where it comes from, so this year we read the documents. In January 1865 General Sherman issued Special Field Order No. 15, setting aside a strip of…
Started by Keisha Monroe2 replies -
Can you be homesick for a place you have never lived?
My grandmother's mother came to Istanbul from Thessaloniki in the population exchange of 1923. My grandmother was born here and never saw the city. But she spoke of it all her life as if it were home, and missed it. Lately, absurdly,…
Started by Elif Yıldız5 replies -
At an Uzbek engagement we break bread instead of signing anything. If the families later part, what has been broken?
In Samarkand, when two families agree on a marriage, there is a small ceremony we call non sindirish, breaking the bread. The groom's family come with bread and gifts, an older woman from each side breaks a round non, and from that…
Started by Dilnoza Karimova3 replies -
Is a jump scare an emotion, or only a reflex the editor pulls?
I spent today cutting a short horror film for a friend. A jump scare is a very simple machine: hold a quiet shot a little too long, let the audience's attention settle, then cut hard to something close to the lens with…
Started by Parisa Moghaddam3 replies -
Must God keep His threats? The Muʿtazila said yes; the Ashʿarites said He may forgive
In the hospital in Cairo families sometimes ask me, when a relative is dying who neglected his prayers for years, whether he will be forgiven. I am an administrator, not a scholar. But the question has sent me back to an old…
Started by Omar Ragab2 replies -
Question of the day: how does saying “I promise” make a promise?
Today's question comes from the card on speech acts: how does saying "I promise" make a promise? Compare two sentences. "I'll pick you up at six." "I promise I'll pick you up at six." The first tells your friend what you expect…
Started by The Editors4 replies -
Reading group: Hobbes’s Leviathan, chapters 14 and 15, on covenants and the Fool, in two evenings
To go with today's question, two chapters in which a hard-headed philosopher tries to explain why anyone should keep a promise at all. The Book corner page is here: Leviathan. Evening one: chapter 14. Hobbes defines the right and the laws of…
Started by The Editors1 reply -
I swore an oath when I enlisted. I’ve been retired three years. Is the oath over?
When I enlisted I stood with the other recruits and swore an oath: to defend the country, to obey lawful orders, to serve faithfully. I meant it. For twenty-two years it shaped everything. I have been retired for three years now. Nobody…
Started by Choi Byeong-hun2 replies -
In Arabic contracts “I sold” means “I hereby sell”. Why would a language make a promise in the past tense?
I translate contracts between Hebrew and Arabic for a living, and one small fact keeps fascinating me. In classical Arabic, and in the jurists' discussions of contracts, the offer and acceptance are typically made in the past tense. The seller says biʿtu,…
Started by Tal Rosen2 replies -
A court of three can release you from a vow. What kind of thing is a promise, if it can be undone from the start?
Our Tuesday group has reached the tractate on vows, and the procedure for releasing them, hatarat nedarim, has turned out to be stranger than any of us expected. If a person regrets a vow, he can go to a sage, or to…
Started by Eliana Halpern2 replies -
“If I don’t sell it, the shop next door will.” Does that excuse selling a remedy I think is useless?
At our pharmacy counter in Ahmedabad we sell a herbal "immunity tonic" that I am fairly sure does nothing. It's legal, cheap and harmless as far as I know. Customers ask for it by name. When I told my father I didn't…
Started by Hetal Shah3 replies -
You promised your daughter you’d be at her school play, and then work calls. Does a promise to a child weigh more or less?
An everyday case. Two weeks ago you promised your eight-year-old you'd be in the front row for her school play on Thursday afternoon. On Wednesday evening your manager asks you to cover an important meeting at the same time. Saying no is…
Started by The Editors2 replies -
Bridges too low for buses: what did Winner mean by “artifacts have politics”?
In a short article about philosophy of technology I read about a bridge built too low for buses to pass under, so that the people who travel by bus could not easily reach what lay beyond it. The article said a philosopher…
Started by Serkan Aydoğdu4 replies -
Why is saying “I promise” not true or false, like other sentences?
I found an idea I don't fully understand. The book says that when I tell my mother "I promise I'll be home by ten", I am not describing anything. I am not reporting a promise that exists somewhere else. Saying it is…
Started by Fajar Nugroho4 replies -
What are the ‘four principles’ of medical ethics, and what do you do when they conflict?
A drug rep who also teaches a short course mentioned "the four principles" as if everyone knew them, and I nodded and then looked them up: autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence and justice. I understand each one on its own. My problem is a…
Started by Hetal Shah4 replies