Skip to content
Coordinates of ThoughtHome of Philosophy
Join
Debate

Thesis

Fraser was right: recognition without redistribution is a consolation prize

Its coordinates: 6.4.1 Distributive Justice

Where it stands

In the Frankfurt School family I come from, the most important quarrel of the last thirty years is between Axel Honneth and Nancy Fraser.

Honneth, building on Hegel, argues that social struggles are at bottom struggles for recognition: for love, for equal rights, for esteem of what one contributes. Even poverty hurts mainly as a form of disrespect, a message that you don't count.

Fraser answers that justice has two dimensions that can't be reduced to each other: recognition (status, respect) and redistribution (income, resources). Her test is "parity of participation": can everyone take part in social life as a peer? Her collection Justice Interruptus (Book corner page) warned that a politics of recognition alone could leave the economy untouched. The two of them argued it out in a joint book, Redistribution or Recognition?

My thesis: Fraser was right. In the welfare-advice sessions I volunteer at, people do want respect. They want to be addressed properly, believed, not treated as cheats. But I have watched offices become far more polite while the amount people actually receive has not kept up with their rent. Recognition was granted. Nothing else changed.

A friendly counter-case is welcome.

LikeReplySaveFollow4 replies

Join the conversation: members reply here, and joining is free. Reading is always free.

Join free to reply Sign in

4 replies

For the thesis 3

  1. Hugo Marchetti

    For Contributor

    For. In the union we have a phrase for this: they gave us a new canteen and a "people strategy" and the same rotas. Respect is real, and the dockers notice it. But a man who is spoken to politely and still can't pay for his daughter's school trip has been recognised as a person with a problem, not as a worker with a claim.

  2. Keisha Monroe

    For Fellow

    For, with a historical twist. In Black Reconstruction Du Bois argued that poor white workers in the South were paid partly in a "public and psychological wage": status, deference and access denied to Black people, instead of better pay. Recognition was used against redistribution, to divide workers who had common material interests.

    That's the strongest reason to side with Fraser. Recognition handed out without redistribution can be a wage paid instead of a wage.

  3. Johanna Reinhardt

    For Fellow

    Dima, that's the counter-case I hoped for, and it shows that neither side can be dropped. Keisha's Du Bois example is chilling and makes my point sharper: recognition can be paid out as a substitute. I'd restate the thesis: either one granted alone can be a consolation prize. Fraser's two dimensions are a protection against both tricks.

Against the thesis 1

  1. Dima Nasser

    Against Fellow

    Against, from the disability movement. For decades disabled people were offered redistribution without recognition: benefits, charity, special institutions, all decided for us. It kept us fed and invisible. The slogan that changed things was "nothing about us without us", which is a demand for recognition first.

    So the consolation prize can run the other way. Money handed down to people who are not recognised as equals buys their silence.