Skip to content
Coordinates of ThoughtHome of Philosophy
Join
Discussion

A court of three can release you from a vow. What kind of thing is a promise, if it can be undone from the start?

Its coordinates: 2.2.5 Revelation

Our Tuesday group has reached the tractate on vows, and the procedure for releasing them, hatarat nedarim, has turned out to be stranger than any of us expected.

If a person regrets a vow, he can go to a sage, or to a court of three ordinary people, who look for an "opening" (petach): some fact or consideration such that, had he thought of it when vowing, he would not have vowed. If they find one, the vow is not cancelled from today. It is treated as void from the start, as if it had been made in error.

The Mishnah itself admits that the laws of releasing vows "hover in the air and have nothing to support them" in Scripture (Hagigah 1:8). And many communities still perform a release of vows before Rosh Hashanah, and recite Kol Nidre on the eve of Yom Kippur.

Two things puzzle the group:

  • Is it a fiction? The person did vow, fully aware. To say "you would not have vowed had you known X" is very often true of anything. Does the procedure reveal a mistake, or invent one?
  • What does it show about promises? If a promise can be undone because the person didn't foresee something, then its force seems to depend on what he knew. Isn't that true of all promises, not only vows?

I'd love to hear how other traditions undo what words have done.

LikeReplySaveFollow2 replies

Join the conversation: members reply here, and joining is free. Reading is always free.

Join free to reply Sign in

2 replies

  1. Miriam Adler

    Fellow

    The tradition was more suspicious of vows than of their release. The Talmud says that whoever vows is as if he built a private altar (Nedarim 22a), which is not a compliment, and Maimonides advises staying away from vows altogether, except to strengthen oneself against a bad habit.

    I read the release procedure in that light. The sages were not inventing mistakes so much as building a safety valve for a practice they thought people used too rashly. The fiction, if it is one, is a merciful fiction: it lets a person step back without admitting that his word means nothing.

  2. Aoife Kilbride

    Contributor

    The Catholic answer is structurally different, and the difference is interesting. In canon law a private vow can be dispensed or commuted by someone with authority, such as a bishop or a parish priest within limits. That doesn't say the vow was void from the start. It says a vow made to God can be released by those God has given authority to bind and loose.

    So your tradition treats release as discovery of an original defect; mine treats it as an act of authority now. The first keeps the person's word clean. The second keeps the vow's history honest, but needs a hierarchy.