Skip to content
Coordinates of ThoughtHome of Philosophy
Join
Debate

Thesis

Compulsory voting makes a democracy more equal, and the small fine is no real loss of liberty

Its coordinates: 6.4.2 Rights and Liberty

Where it stands

Several democracies, Australia, Belgium and Brazil among them, require citizens to turn up and vote, with a modest fine for those who don't. The idea has been proposed in India more than once.

My thesis: compulsory voting makes a democracy more equal, and the cost to liberty is trivial.

Equality. Where voting is voluntary, turnout is lowest among the poor, the young and the less educated. Politicians respond to people who vote. So voluntary voting quietly gives some citizens more weight than others, which a democracy should regard as a defect, not a choice.

Liberty. What is required is attendance, not a vote for anyone; in most systems you can spoil your ballot. Mill thought voting was a public trust, not a private right, and argued that it should be exercised under the eye of the public. The duty to serve on a jury, or to fill in a census form, is a far heavier burden, and we accept it.

The obvious objections: the right to vote includes the right not to; compelled voters may be uninformed or angry; and a state that compels participation might start to treat it as a show of consent.

I'm a law student, so I'll warn you that I will argue with everyone.

LikeReplySaveFollow4 replies

Join the conversation: members reply here, and joining is free. Reading is always free.

Join free to reply Sign in

4 replies

For the thesis 2

  1. Bec Doyle

    For Contributor

    For, from Australia, where it's been the rule since the 1920s. Nobody I know experiences it as tyranny. It's a Saturday morning at the local school with a sausage from the fundraising barbecue on the way out. That ritual matters more than people think: it makes voting a thing the whole street does, not a thing for people who are "into politics".

    And yes, you can draw a picture on your ballot. Some people do.

  2. Deepa Kartha

    For Contributor

    Dana, I agree compulsion is not enough, but it changes the incentives for exactly the "they" your neighbour means. Once the poor district votes at the same rate as the rich one, candidates have to campaign there. Zainab, your example is the strongest point against me, and I accept it: compulsion is only defensible where the choice is already free. Which is why I said "a democracy" and not "a state".

Against the thesis 2

  1. Zainab Kadhim

    Against Fellow

    Against. I have lived where the vote was compulsory in practice, and a hundred per cent turned out, and it meant nothing. I know that Bec's country is not that country. But the reason it isn't has nothing to do with compulsion; it has to do with free choice among real alternatives.

    Compulsion adds numbers. What makes a vote matter is that refusing to vote is also a way of speaking, and in some places the only one left. I would not give up that silence lightly.

  2. Dana Whitfield

    Against Contributor

    Against, from organizing. The people Deepa wants to bring in don't stay home because nobody fined them. They stay home because, as one woman told me, "they decide everything anyway." A fine gets them to the booth. It doesn't give them a reason to believe their vote changes anything.

    Rousseau's old complaint, that people are free only on election day, gets worse, not better, if we make election day mandatory and do nothing about the other 364.