Skip to content
Coordinates of ThoughtHome of Philosophy
Join
Question · Open

Question of the day: are you free when nobody stops you, or only when you could actually do it?

Its coordinates: 6.4.2 Rights and Liberty

Today's question comes from the card on rights and liberty: are you free when nobody stops you, or when you could actually do it?

A young woman is legally free to study medicine. No law forbids it. But the fees are more than her family will ever have, and the nearest medical school is four hundred kilometres away. Is she free to become a doctor?

The main answers:

  • Freedom is the absence of interference. Hobbes defined liberty as the absence of external impediments. Isaiah Berlin's "negative liberty" is the area within which nobody stops you. On this view she is free; she is also poor, and poverty is a different misfortune.
  • Freedom is what you can actually do or be. Amartya Sen's capability approach measures freedom by the real options a person has. A right she cannot use is, for her, a right on paper.
  • Freedom is not living at someone's mercy. Republicans such as Philip Pettit say you are unfree whenever someone could interfere at will, even if they never do. A servant with a kind master is still a servant.
  • Freedom is self-mastery. Berlin's "positive liberty": being governed by your own reason rather than by impulse or by others. Berlin distrusted it, because rulers can claim to know your "real" self better than you do.

The card sets out these positions and their critics: 6.4.2 Rights and Liberty.

Answer in your own terms. A freedom you had on paper but not in practice is a good place to start.

LikeAnswerSaveFollow5 answers

Join the conversation: members reply here, and joining is free. Reading is always free.

Join free to reply Sign in

5 answers

  1. Javier Ferrandis

    Fellow

    The first answer is weaker than it looks even on its own terms. G. A. Cohen made the point in his essay on freedom and money: try to board a train without a ticket and you will be stopped, first by the conductor and in the end by the police. Lacking money is not just lacking an ability. It is being liable to interference.

    If she walks into the lecture hall without paying the fees, someone will remove her. So even Hobbes's definition counts her as unfree. You don't need Sen to say it. You only need to ask who would come and stop her.

  2. Thandeka Mokoena

    Fellow

    The republican answer is the one I see every week. Most of the families I work with have no written lease. Their landlord has never evicted them. Some landlords are even kind. But every month they could be told to leave, and so every month they do not complain about the broken geyser, do not have relatives to stay, do not join the tenants' committee.

    Nobody is interfering with them, and they are not free. That is exactly Pettit's point: the harm is in living under the possibility.

  3. Baraka Mwakyusa

    Fellow

    Nobody stops me opening a shop in the big new mall. In ten years I could not afford one. I don't feel "free but poor", I feel not free.

    But my uncle says that if the government gave me the shop, then I would be free and also owe the government. Is that not Pettit's servant again, only with a kind state as the master?

  4. Henrike Vogel

    Contributor

    Let me defend Berlin a little, because he is often read as if he did not care about the poor. He did. His point was about clear words. In "Two Concepts" he says that everything is what it is: liberty is liberty, not equality or fairness or justice or culture, or human happiness or a quiet conscience.

    He thought the young woman's situation is an injustice, and a serious one. He only refused to call it a lack of liberty, because once every good is renamed freedom, a ruler can take away your liberty in the name of giving you more of it. Baraka's uncle has understood him perfectly.

  5. Deepa Kartha

    Contributor

    Ambedkar put the three ideas together in his last speech to the Constituent Assembly in November 1949. Liberty cannot be divorced from equality, he said, equality cannot be divorced from liberty, and neither can be divorced from fraternity. Without equality, liberty would produce the supremacy of the few over the many.

    He was not confusing concepts, as Henrike's Berlin might suspect. He was describing what happens in a society with caste. A Dalit in a village was legally free to draw water from the common well long before he could do it without being beaten. Berlin's clean definition is correct and, in that village, almost useless.