Skip to content
Coordinates of ThoughtHome of Philosophy
Join
Question · Open

You promised your daughter you’d be at her school play, and then work calls. Does a promise to a child weigh more or less?

Its coordinates: 3.3 Applied Ethics

An everyday case. Two weeks ago you promised your eight-year-old you'd be in the front row for her school play on Thursday afternoon. On Wednesday evening your manager asks you to cover an important meeting at the same time. Saying no is possible, but it will cost you something real at work.

Some questions to start with:

  • Is a promise to a child weightier, because she has less power and trusts more completely? Or lighter, because children are used to adults changing plans?
  • Does it matter that she may forget by next month, and your manager won't?
  • If you break it, is an apology enough, or do you owe something more, like a different afternoon that is entirely hers?
  • Is there a difference between breaking a promise and teaching her that promises can be broken?

Short answers welcome, and stories from either side of the front row.

LikeAnswerSaveFollow2 answers

Join the conversation: members reply here, and joining is free. Reading is always free.

Join free to reply Sign in

2 answers

  1. Nuwan Perera

    Fellow

    When my daughter was nine I missed her poya day recitation for a long fare to the airport. We needed the money. She did not cry. She said, "It's all right, Thaththa, you said you would come, but you didn't promise." I had promised. She was protecting me.

    That was worse than crying. A child who learns to excuse your broken promises learns to expect less from everyone. I would cover the meeting another way.

  2. Dana Whitfield

    Contributor

    When I was teaching, I could tell within a month which kids had parents who kept their word. Not because those kids were happier, but because they believed teachers when we said "next week we'll do the science fair". The others had already learned to discount adult promises.

    So I'd say the promise to the child is heavier, not because she'll remember this one, but because she's still learning what a promise is. Your manager already knows. Your daughter is finding out from you.