Coordinates of Thought: philosophy questions, debates and reading groups from every tradition
-
What are the ‘four principles’ of medical ethics, and what do you do when they conflict?
A drug rep who also teaches a short course mentioned "the four principles" as if everyone knew them, and I nodded and then looked them up: autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence and justice. I understand each one on its own. My problem is a…
Started by Hetal Shah4 replies -
As the eldest son I’m expected to keep the ancestral altar. Can a duty bind you that you never agreed to?
In our family, as in most Vietnamese families, the ancestral altar passes to the eldest son, and with it the duties: incense on the first and fifteenth of the lunar month, the death-anniversary meals (giỗ) when relatives gather, the care of the…
Started by Vũ Quốc Bảo3 replies -
A search engine’s ranking is a claim about what matters, and it should answer for it like a publisher
A ranking looks like a measurement. It's really a choice. Out of millions of pages, ten appear first, in an order, and most people never look past the first three. Whatever the engine's designers intend, that order says: these are the ones…
Started by Derek Hollis3 replies -
A founder owes early employees more than their contracts say
The first five people who joined my company took half the salary they could have had elsewhere. They worked nights and weekends for two years, because they believed what I told them about where we were going. They were given small amounts…
Started by Rohan Desai3 replies -
Hiya is translated as “shame”, but my students use it to mean “consideration”. Is it a virtue or a leash?
In my Philosophy of the Human Person class we reached the emotions, and I asked my sixteen-year-olds to describe hiya. The textbook says "shame". The students disagreed. Nakakahiya can mean "embarrassing", yes, but also "I don't want to impose on you". When…
Started by Rowena Abellana3 replies -
Data about you should be yours to sell
To go with today's question, a motion about information that is very much about money. The motion: data about you should be your property, and yours to sell. For the motion: you already give it away, and others profit. Ownership would give…
Started by The Editors4 replies -
Reading group: the Egyptian story of writing in Plato’s Phaedrus (274b–278e), in two evenings
I catalogue manuscripts in Alexandria, a city founded on the opposite bet from the one Plato's Egyptian king makes. So I'd like to read his story with others. The Book corner page is here: Phaedrus. Near the end of the Phaedrus, Socrates…
Started by Mona Fathy2 replies -
From the Book corner: Saussure’s Course in General Linguistics, and meaning made of differences
This week's book from the Book corner is Ferdinand de Saussure's Course in General Linguistics. Saussure never wrote it. It was put together after his death, and published in 1916, by two colleagues working mainly from students' notes on his lectures in…
Started by The Editors1 reply -
Fraser was right: recognition without redistribution is a consolation prize
In the Frankfurt School family I come from, the most important quarrel of the last thirty years is between Axel Honneth and Nancy Fraser. Honneth, building on Hegel, argues that social struggles are at bottom struggles for recognition: for love, for equal…
Started by Johanna Reinhardt4 replies -
In Kariakoo a tourist paid triple for a charger and left smiling. If he never finds out, did I cheat him?
I sell phone accessories in Kariakoo market. Everybody bargains. A local customer knows the price of a charger, more or less, and we argue until we meet. Last week a tourist did not bargain at all. I said a price three times…
Started by Baraka Mwakyusa4 replies -
A few stickers make our vision model read a stop sign as a speed limit. Did it misperceive, or never perceive at all?
I build computer-vision systems. A few years ago researchers showed that a handful of black and white stickers, placed carefully on a real stop sign, could make a trained classifier read it as a speed-limit sign, from many angles and distances. No…
Started by Priya Raghavan2 replies -
Generative AI deepens alienation in exactly Marx’s sense
We have a thread on Marx and the gig economy. I want to make a narrower claim about generative AI. In the Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844, Marx describes four dimensions of alienated labour: workers are alienated from the product of…
Started by Javier Ferrandis6 replies -
After the birth she chose sterilisation and begged us not to tell her husband’s family. Whose secret is it?
On our ward last month a woman gave birth to her fourth child by caesarean. Before the operation she asked the doctor, clearly and more than once, to tie her tubes at the same time. She is an adult, the doctor recorded…
Started by Farhana Akter3 replies -
My daughter asks why Buddhist countries keep armies if the first precept forbids killing. What do I tell her?
My daughter is fourteen and has started reading the history book from school with a pencil in her hand. This week she asked me something I could not answer. Every poya day we take the five precepts, and the first is to…
Started by Nuwan Perera2 replies -
Why did the Vaiśeṣikas count direction as a substance?
I teach physics and spend weekends exposing miracle tricks for a rationalist association, so I like the Indian schools that tried to describe the world piece by piece. The Vaiśeṣika list of nine substances is a favourite of mine: earth, water, fire,…
Started by Arvind Poojary4 replies -
Cheng Yi said to investigate one thing today and another tomorrow. Is a phone full of facts the same thing?
The Great Learning says that extending knowledge lies in "investigating things" (gewu). Cheng Yi gave practical advice on how: investigate one thing today and another thing tomorrow, and after accumulating enough, there comes a point where everything suddenly links up. Zhu Xi…
Started by Lin Pei-shan2 replies -
Reading group: Joseph Butler’s Rolls Chapel sermons on self-love and benevolence, over two weeks
For today's question, a reading group on the most careful early reply to the claim that everyone is selfish. The text: Joseph Butler, Fifteen Sermons Preached at the Rolls Chapel (1726): book page. Butler was preaching to lawyers, and it shows: the…
Started by The Editors1 reply -
My mother still reads my messages, and I’m eighteen. Is privacy something you can have inside a family?
I'm eighteen and on a gap year in Jakarta. My mother still picks up my phone when I leave it on the table and reads my messages. When I object she says: "If you have nothing to hide, why do you care?"…
Started by Fajar Nugroho3 replies -
A student wants to translate vijñapti-mātra as “information only”. Helpful, or a false friend?
In our evening group we are reading Vasubandhu's Twenty Verses (Book corner page). It opens with the claim that all this is vijñapti-mātra, because nonexistent objects appear, as when someone with an eye disease sees hairs that are not there. The standard…
Started by Kenneth Lam Chi-ho2 replies -
Divers say kelp grows its floats “to reach the light”. Is purpose talk in biology a fallacy, or a shorthand that earns its keep?
When I teach new divers in the kelp forests off Valparaíso, I say things like: the giant kelp grows little gas-filled floats in order to hold its blades up near the light. Everyone understands. Then a student who studies chemistry objected: "Plants…
Started by Ignacio Cárcamo1 reply -
Reading group: Floridi’s The Fourth Revolution, on hyperhistory and the four shocks to our self-image, in two evenings
To go with today's question, a short book by the philosopher who has done most to make "information" a philosophical subject in its own right. The Book corner page is here: The Fourth Revolution. Luciano Floridi (2014) argues that our self-understanding has…
Started by The Editors1 reply -
Does Islamic philosophy end with Ibn Rushd? What the post-classical evidence shows
The story that philosophy in Islam died in the twelfth century was persuasive for a long time. Logic textbooks, Illuminationist commentaries, Safavid metaphysics and Ottoman and South Asian scholarship tell a different story, though one real disagreement remains.
Written by The Editors3 replies -
Our model never sees anyone’s religion, but it can guess it from what they buy. Is an inference a disclosure?
Our team builds models on loyalty-card data for a retail group in Kuala Lumpur. By policy we never collect race or religion. They are not columns in any table. Last month a colleague showed, as a curiosity, that a simple model could…
Started by Nur Aisyah Rahman3 replies -
My pupils can recite the Veda perfectly without knowing what it means. Has anything been learned?
My family has taught Sanskrit in Varanasi for five generations. Some of my boys can recite long sections of the Veda with every pitch accent correct, through the pada, krama and ghana patterns, which weave the words forwards and backwards so that…
Started by Govinda Prasad Upadhyaya2 replies -
Automated cranes at my port: freedom from drudgery, or the end of what gave the day shape?
The port where I operate a gantry crane has announced that the new terminal will be automated: cranes run remotely from an office, straddle carriers without drivers. Some of us will retrain to sit at screens. Most won't be needed. As a…
Started by Hugo Marchetti1 reply -
A sharing app shows your friend was on your street last night and didn’t call in. Do you mention it?
You and a close friend share your locations on your phones, for safety, after one of you walked home late and the other worried. Neither of you checks very often. On Sunday you happen to open the app and see that on…
Started by The Editors2 replies -
Question of the day: is information something in the world, or something we bring to it?
Today's question comes from the card on philosophy of information: is information something in the world, or something we bring to it? A pine is felled at the edge of a forest. It has sixty rings. Before anyone counts them, did the…
Started by The Editors3 replies -
In Toledo one man read the Arabic aloud in Castilian and another wrote it down in Latin. Whose understanding ended up in the book?
On my walking tours I mostly talk about Córdoba, but the question guests ask that I can't answer is about Toledo. In the twelfth century much of Ibn Sīnā reached Latin Europe through a peculiar relay. In the preface to the Latin…
Started by Rafael Lucena Prieto2 replies -
Integrity, proportion, radiance: does Aquinas have a theory of beauty or just three words?
In a seminar on Aquinas we hit the passage everyone quotes on beauty: Summa theologiae I, question 39, article 8, where he says beauty requires three things: integrity or perfection (things that are lacking are ugly for that reason), due proportion or…
Started by Aoife Kilbride1 reply -
I use modal logic at work every day, and the engineers around me have no idea it was philosophy
Every day, the engineers I work with write properties like "on every path, whenever a request is issued, a grant eventually follows". In our notation that's something like AG(request → AF grant): A for "on all paths", G for "always", F for…
Started by Derek Hollis1 reply