Skip to content
Coordinates of ThoughtHome of Philosophy
Join
Reading Group

Reading group: the Egyptian story of writing in Plato’s Phaedrus (274b–278e), in two evenings

Its coordinates: 6.18 Philosophy of Information

I catalogue manuscripts in Alexandria, a city founded on the opposite bet from the one Plato's Egyptian king makes. So I'd like to read his story with others. The Book corner page is here: Phaedrus.

Near the end of the Phaedrus, Socrates tells of the god Theuth, inventor of numbers, geometry, astronomy and letters, who brings his inventions to Thamus, king of Egypt. Theuth presents writing as a drug (pharmakon) for memory and wisdom. Thamus replies that it will do the opposite: those who learn it will stop exercising memory and rely on external marks. Writing is a drug for reminding, not for memory, and it gives the appearance of wisdom, not wisdom itself.

Socrates adds that written words are like paintings: ask them a question and they keep silent, or say the same thing for ever. They cannot defend themselves without their father.

Evening one: 274b–275e, the myth and the comparison with painting.

Evening two: 276a–278e, the "living word" written in the soul, and the strange image of gardens of Adonis.

Questions to bring: Is a database a reminder or a memory? And what do we make of the fact that Plato wrote all this down? Derrida's essay "Plato's Pharmacy" has a lot to say about that word pharmakon, which can mean both remedy and poison.

LikeReplySaveFollow2 replies

Join the conversation: members reply here, and joining is free. Reading is always free.

Join free to reply Sign in

2 replies

  1. Giulia Ferrante

    Fellow

    I'll come for the gardens of Adonis, because my students always trip on them. These were pots of seeds forced to sprout quickly in summer for a festival, and left to wither in days. Socrates says a sensible farmer wouldn't plant his serious seeds there. Writing, he suggests, is that kind of garden: done for play and festivity, while serious sowing happens in conversation.

    As for Plato writing it down: he wrote dialogues, which are the nearest thing to a text that answers back.

  2. Titilayo Adeyemi

    Fellow

    I'd like to join for evening one. My grandmother could recite oríkì for an hour, and Thamus is half right about her: her memory was far stronger than mine, because she never had a book to lean on.

    But Socrates's complaint that written words can't answer questions applies to oral praise poetry too. You cannot interrupt an oríkì and ask it what it meant. Recitation can be as fixed as writing. What answers back is a person, not a medium.