Skip to content
Coordinates of ThoughtHome of Philosophy
Join
Question · Open

After the birth she chose sterilisation and begged us not to tell her husband’s family. Whose secret is it?

Its coordinates: 3.3.1 Bioethics and Medical Ethics

On our ward last month a woman gave birth to her fourth child by caesarean. Before the operation she asked the doctor, clearly and more than once, to tie her tubes at the same time. She is an adult, the doctor recorded her consent, and it was done.

She also begged all of us not to tell her mother-in-law, who wants more grandsons and runs the household.

The next morning the mother-in-law caught me alone in the corridor and asked me directly what the doctor had done "inside".

I had three choices, and all of them felt wrong:

  1. Lie. Say nothing was done but the birth.
  2. Refuse. Say "you must ask the doctor". But everyone in that family would hear a refusal as an answer.
  3. Tell. Respect an elder's direct question, which is how I was raised.

I chose the second. She looked at me for a long time and walked away.

In the principles of medical ethics I've read, confidentiality belongs to the patient, not to the family. But in the families I serve, a woman's body is not treated as only hers. And I don't know whether a refusal that everyone understands is really any different from telling.

Whose secret was it? And was I allowed to lie for her?

LikeAnswerSaveFollow3 answers

Join the conversation: members reply here, and joining is free. Reading is always free.

Join free to reply Sign in

3 answers

  1. Tsion Bekele

    Contributor

    Families in Addis ask me the same kind of question in corridors, because the interpreter seems less official than the doctor. My rule now is to speak from my role: "I only carry the patient's words. What happened to her is hers to tell." I say it the same way every time, whatever the question, so that the refusal itself doesn't carry information.

    That's the trick, I think. A refusal reveals something only if you refuse selectively.

  2. Omar Ragab

    Contributor

    Tsion's rule is good, but it shouldn't have to be invented by each of you in a corridor. A hospital should have a written line that every staff member gives to every family, so that "ask the doctor" is just what this ward always says.

    On lying: I would not lie for her, not because the truth is owed to the mother-in-law, but because the chart exists. If the family learns later from a document that staff lied, the patient is in more danger, not less. The secret is hers; so is the risk, and a lie can increase it.

  3. Farhana Akter

    Contributor

    Tsion, "refuse the same way every time" is so simple that I'm ashamed I didn't think of it. I will ask our sister-in-charge whether we can all use one sentence. Omar, I hadn't thought of the chart. The woman came back for her stitches last week. She held my hand and said nothing, which I took as thanks.