Coordinates of Thought: philosophy questions, debates and reading groups from every tradition
-
When people say morality is “objective”, what exactly are they claiming?
I'm new to moral philosophy. In one of my classes a lecturer said moral judgments are "just evolved emotions", and a friend from the philosophy department said that was a confused claim because morality is objective. I realised I don't know what…
Started by Elif Yıldız4 replies -
Compulsory voting makes a democracy more equal, and the small fine is no real loss of liberty
Several democracies, Australia, Belgium and Brazil among them, require citizens to turn up and vote, with a modest fine for those who don't. The idea has been proposed in India more than once. My thesis: compulsory voting makes a democracy more equal,…
Started by Deepa Kartha4 replies -
Plantinga’s proper function: does warrant need a designer, or will evolution do?
This term a student asked me a question I could not answer cleanly, so I bring it here. Alvin Plantinga's account of warrant, in Warrant and Proper Function (1993), says roughly that a belief has warrant if it is produced by cognitive…
Started by Ikechukwu Anyanwu1 reply -
I braked hard, a passenger fell and broke her wrist, and nobody blames me. Why do I still feel I owe her?
Three weeks ago on the 413 a car cut in front of me at a junction. I braked hard. An older woman who was standing near the middle doors fell and broke her wrist. The company checked the camera. The inspector said…
Started by Serkan Aydoğdu3 replies -
Remorse should count for nothing at sentencing, because no court can see it
In thirty-one years of reporting from the courts of Lahore I watched a great many defendants weep before sentence. The ones with better lawyers wept better. Some of the ones I believed most were the ones who could not speak at all.…
Started by Khalid Mahmood Awan4 replies -
From the Book corner: Sidgwick’s The Methods of Ethics, and the quarrel he could not settle
This week's book from the Book corner is Henry Sidgwick's The Methods of Ethics, first published in 1874. It is long and patient, and many philosophers, Rawls and Parfit among them, have counted it among the best books on ethics ever written.…
Started by The Editors2 replies -
My friend and I disagree about eating meat, and neither of us is careless. Should we both be less sure?
My closest friend from university stopped eating meat four years ago. I didn't. We have argued about it over many lunches, and I can't find anything wrong with her reasoning except the conclusion. She says the same about mine. At work, if…
Started by Wanjiru Njenga3 replies -
Our church fasts on nearly half the days of the year. Is fasting a moral practice, or only a religious one?
In the Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahedo Church we fast on Wednesdays and Fridays through most of the year, for the fifty-five days before Easter, and in several other seasons. On fasting days we eat no meat, eggs or milk, and traditionally nothing at…
Started by Dawit Gebremedhin2 replies -
Nel Noddings said our obligation to care stops at those we can meet. Honest, or a failure of care ethics?
I volunteer on a palliative-care unit in Montreal, and care ethics describes what I see there better than any other theory. The good of the night is not a sum of pleasures or a rule kept. It is attention to one person…
Started by Nadia Haddad2 replies -
Our constitution says “do not be lazy, do not lie, do not steal”. Can a state have virtues, or only laws?
When my grandchildren were helping me read our constitution of 2009, we found Article 8. It says the State takes on and promotes, as the ethical and moral principles of our plural society, ama qhilla, ama llulla, ama suwa: do not be…
Started by Lucía Mamani2 replies -
Mill was wrong: a bad motive can make an otherwise helpful act wrong
In chapter two of Utilitarianism, Mill writes that "he who saves a fellow creature from drowning does what is morally right, whether his motive be duty, or the hope of being paid for his trouble". The motive, he says, bears on the…
Started by The Editors4 replies -
My honesty came from my mother and from Kariakoo market. Is it to my credit?
I sell phone accessories in Kariakoo. I give honest prices now (after I asked a question here about a tourist who paid triple, and was told off in a very educated way). My regular customers trust me. At dinner my uncle said…
Started by Baraka Mwakyusa3 replies -
One appointment left and two patients who need it. What should a receptionist go by?
For thirty-four years I managed a GP surgery in Leith, and the hardest decisions in the building were often made by the receptionists, not the doctors. A Friday morning. One appointment left. At 8:01 an elderly regular rings: his chest "isn't right",…
Started by Alistair Gow3 replies -
Reading group: Walzer’s Spheres of Justice, chapter one on complex equality, over two evenings
I work at a cooperative bank, which means every week I see money trying to cross into places it shouldn't. Michael Walzer's Spheres of Justice (1983) is the book that gave me words for it. The Book corner page is here: Spheres…
Started by Javier Ferrandis1 reply -
Epicurus’s hedonism is virtue ethics under another name
I sit on tasting panels, and the longer I do it the less I think pleasure and judgement are separate things. Which is why Epicurus has started to look to me like a virtue ethicist who chose a misleading slogan. The thesis:…
Started by Bec Doyle4 replies -
When the victim’s family may pardon a killer: is that mercy built into law, or justice for sale?
For thirty-one years I watched murder trials in Lahore. The moment I remember most from many of them is not the verdict. It is the family of the dead man, often in the corridor, deciding whether to forgive. In Islamic law, for…
Started by Khalid Mahmood Awan4 replies -
My friend is generous to me and cruel to the people who work for him. Should I stay his friend?
An old friend of mine runs a small printing business. To me he has always been generous: he lent me money when the bookshop had a bad winter and never mentioned it again. To the people who work for him he is…
Started by Sasha Kovalenko2 replies -
Palmares lived for most of a century outside colonial law. What made its law legitimate?
At our community centre in Salvador, the children learn about Palmares every November, because 20 November, the day Zumbi was killed in 1695, is now Black Consciousness Day. Palmares was a quilombo, a settlement of people who had escaped slavery, in the…
Started by Jorge Bonfim2 replies -
Utu gets translated as “revenge”. Is it closer to justice, or to keeping a balance?
My senior students are doing a history unit, and one of their textbooks explains the wars of the early nineteenth century by "utu", translated as "revenge" or "payback". The students were annoyed, and so was I. Utu is the same word we…
Started by Aroha Tipene3 replies -
The Tirukkuṟaḷ makes hospitality a householder’s duty. Does it still bind in a block of flats?
I read the Tirukkuṟaḷ with my children in Tamil, a couplet or two after dinner. Last week we reached the chapter on hospitality, in the part on the householder's life (the Tirukkural has a Book corner page). Valluvar is very direct: the…
Started by Thamarai Raman5 replies -
My daughter asked what mosquitoes are for. Is there an honest answer?
We were swatting mosquitoes on the balcony in Penang and my eight-year-old asked, quite seriously, "What are mosquitoes for?" I said something vague about food for birds and she said, "But that's what they're for for the birds. What are they for…
Started by Thamarai Raman4 replies -
Sor Juana’s First Dream: the mind tries to grasp the whole universe in one look, and fails
In her Reply to Sor Filotea (1691), Sor Juana says she does not remember writing anything for her own pleasure except a little paper called "The Dream". That paper is Primero sueño, nearly a thousand lines long, published in 1692, and it…
Started by Valentina Ríos1 reply -
Reading group: Hursthouse’s On Virtue Ethics, chapter one on right action, in two evenings
To go with today's question, one chapter that gives virtue ethics a direct answer to it. The Book corner page is here: On Virtue Ethics. Rosalind Hursthouse's book (1999) is the most influential modern statement of a neo-Aristotelian ethics. Its first chapter,…
Started by The Editors1 reply -
Question of the day: what should you look at to tell whether an act is right?
Today's question comes from the card on normative ethics: what should I look at to tell whether an act is right? Take a small case. A neighbour asks you to water her plants while she is away. You forget for a week,…
Started by The Editors5 replies -
Speedrunners clip through walls the designers never meant them to pass. Are they still playing our game?
I design puzzle games, and last month I watched someone finish one of ours in four minutes. It's meant to take six hours. He walked into a corner at a particular angle, the physics glitched, and he fell through the floor into…
Started by Hsieh Wei-ting1 reply -
Accounts must give a “true and fair view”. Is fairness a second standard on top of truth?
Accountants in Ireland and Britain work under a phrase nobody has ever defined: company accounts must give a "true and fair view". And it has teeth. If following a particular accounting rule would fail to give a true and fair view, the…
Started by Siobhán Keane2 replies -
Adab, li and hexis: is character trained the same way in three traditions?
When a girl comes to learn batik in my mother's workshop, she doesn't begin by drawing. She begins by preparing cloth, heating wax, watching. She learns how to sit, how to hold the canting, how to speak to the older women. After…
Started by Ratna Wulandari1 reply -
A mother asks me to move her daughter away from a “bad influence”. Al-Ghazālī would side with her. Should I?
I teach at a girls' secondary school in Abu Dhabi. This week a mother asked me to seat her daughter away from a classmate. The classmate is not rude or dishonest. She is loud, her family arrived recently, and they are, the…
Started by Hessa Al Mazrouei2 replies -
Reporting the optimistic end of an honest range: is that lying with true numbers?
In reservoir engineering we never give one number for how much oil a field holds. We give a range. P90 is the volume we are 90 per cent confident of exceeding, P50 the middle, P10 the hopeful case. Every figure comes out…
Started by Abdulrahman Al-Bassam2 replies -
Rousseau said the English were free only at election time. Was he right about the rest of us?
In Book III of The Social Contract, Rousseau has a line that hit me hard: the English people think they are free, but they are badly mistaken; they are free only during the election of members of Parliament, and once those are…
Started by Dana Whitfield1 reply