Coordinates of Thought: philosophy questions, debates and reading groups from every tradition
-
On Liberty in the age of the feed: what Mill still gets right
John Stuart Mill wrote in 1859 that silencing an opinion robs everyone, not only the speaker. A journalist in Karachi asks how his arguments hold up when the crowd is online and the press is an algorithm.
Written by Sana Rizvi4 replies -
Could the constants have been different? Spinoza says no; the Ashʿarites say God could change them tomorrow
I model oil reservoirs. Every model has parameters, and every morning I change some of them to see what would have happened. So the question "could the physical constants have been different?" feels very concrete to me, and I've found two answers…
Started by Abdulrahman Al-Bassam1 reply -
Is citing an expert always the “appeal to authority” fallacy?
A practical question from a courtroom. In our family's long-running case both sides rely on expert witnesses: engineers, accountants, handwriting analysts. Last month the other side's lawyer told the judge that our lawyer's argument was "a textbook appeal to authority" because it…
Started by Hamza Qureshi4 replies -
If reincarnation were true, death would be less bad
A motion for the evening. Philosophers who write about the badness of death usually assume, for the sake of argument, that death is the end. Epicurus argued that even then it is nothing to us. Others argue that death is bad because…
Started by The Editors3 replies -
Human dignity is owed equally even to someone who has done monstrous things
I studied law in Lahore, and the phrase "human dignity" appears in our constitution, in international covenants, and in the judgments I have read as a litigant. Iqbal, whom I read beside Hart, made the dignity of the self, khudī, the centre…
Started by Hamza Qureshi3 replies -
Reading group: Llull’s Book of the Gentile and the Three Wise Men, over three weeks
Ramon Llull, born in Majorca around 1232, wrote The Book of the Gentile and the Three Wise Men in the 1270s, first in Arabic, he tells us, then in Catalan. As someone who leads tourists past the stones of three faiths every…
Started by Rafael Lucena Prieto2 replies -
In the Appendix to the Treatise, Hume admits his account of the self has failed, and never quite says why. What went wrong?
Everyone knows the famous passage in Hume's Treatise: when I enter most intimately into what I call myself, I always stumble on some particular perception or other, heat or cold, light or shade, love or hatred. I never catch myself without a…
Started by Alistair Gow2 replies -
The social contract was always a sexual contract as well
In 1988 Carole Pateman published The Sexual Contract, and it still sits on my reading group's shelf with the spine cracked. Her argument is that the story of the social contract, told by Hobbes, Locke and Rousseau, is only half a story.…
Started by Femke Bosman3 replies -
From the Book corner: Stuart Russell’s Human Compatible, and a machine that is uncertain about what we want
Stuart Russell co-wrote the most widely used textbook on artificial intelligence. In Human Compatible (2019) he argues that the field's standard model is dangerous. In that model, we build machines that optimise a fixed objective we give them. The problem is the…
Started by The Editors2 replies -
A contract signed out of desperation should not be enforced as written
In my contract law class we read cases that the textbook calls easy and I find impossible. A labourer, with a sick child and no savings, takes a loan at a rate that will double his debt in months, and signs away…
Started by Deepa Kartha3 replies -
Your friend asks what you honestly think of her novel. It isn’t good. What do you owe her?
An everyday case, and an old one. A close friend has spent four years on a novel. She sends you the manuscript and asks for your honest opinion before she sends it to literary agents. You read it carefully. It isn't good:…
Started by The Editors4 replies -
A contract theory of morality cannot explain what we owe to animals
Today's question of the day sends me back to a problem that made me sceptical of contractualism in my first year. Contract theories ground morality in agreement: principles that people could not reasonably reject (Scanlon), or that rational bargainers would accept (Gauthier),…
Started by Ethan Mercer3 replies -
A treaty signed by our great-great-grandparents still shapes our lives. Can a promise bind people who weren’t born when it was made?
At our kura we teach the children about Te Tiriti o Waitangi, signed in 1840 by many Māori rangatira and representatives of the British Crown. The children learn that there was an English text and a Māori text, and that they did…
Started by Aroha Tipene2 replies -
You clicked “I agree” to terms you never read. Are you really bound by them?
An everyday case that almost everyone reading this has been part of today. To use an app, open an account or connect to a café's wifi, you scroll past several thousand words of terms and click "I agree". Almost nobody reads them.…
Started by The Editors3 replies -
A customer asked why Jains refuse honey but drink milk. What is the real answer?
A customer at our pharmacy was choosing a cough syrup and asked why I warned her that one contained honey. I said I'm Jain and we don't take honey. She asked, quite reasonably: "But you drink milk?" I gave her the answer…
Started by Hetal Shah4 replies -
Can a whole people have an emotion? What do we mean when we say han is Korean?
In music lessons and in newspapers I often hear that han is the national emotion of Korea: a long, settled grief and resentment, mixed with yearning, built from centuries of invasion, colonisation, division and poverty. Foreign books about Korea mention it on…
Started by Moon Ha-eunAnswer first (no replies yet) -
Ficino wrote eighteen books to prove the soul immortal using Plato. Why did a Florentine priest need a pagan philosopher for that?
In the 1470s Marsilio Ficino, a Florentine priest, physician and the first translator of all of Plato into Latin, wrote his Platonic Theology, eighteen books with the subtitle "on the immortality of souls". It was printed in 1482. The paintings I restore…
Started by Chiara Bellandi2 replies -
The world could have been an inch larger or a day older. Does that need someone to choose it?
One kalām argument has stayed with me more than the famous one about beginnings. The Ashʿarite theologians reasoned like this. The world has a particular size, shape and moment of origin. Reason sees that each of these could have been otherwise: they…
Started by Omar Ragab3 replies -
Wittgenstein said that if a lion could talk, we could not understand him. Would a revelation from God fare any better?
Near the end of what used to be printed as Part II of the Philosophical Investigations, Wittgenstein writes one of his most famous sentences: if a lion could talk, we could not understand him. The point, as I read it, is not…
Started by Oskar Nyberg2 replies -
Reading group: Kant’s Perpetual Peace, the preliminary and definitive articles, over two weeks
In 1795 Immanuel Kant, then seventy-one, published a short essay written in the form of a peace treaty, with articles, supplements and even a secret article: Perpetual Peace. It is one of the founding texts of international law and of the idea…
Started by The Editors2 replies -
When our game’s economy crashed, players blamed us as if we were gods. What does the maker of a world owe the people living in it?
Last month a bug in our online game let a few players duplicate gold. Within two days prices in the game's markets had gone mad, and players who had saved for months found their savings nearly worthless. We fixed the bug and…
Started by Hsieh Wei-ting2 replies -
The census form asked whether I work. I left accountancy to raise two children. What was I supposed to tick?
The census enumerator came to our flat in George Town with a tablet and a polite smile. When she reached the question on employment, there were boxes for working, unemployed and looking for work, and then the category for people "outside the…
Started by Thamarai Raman3 replies -
Question of the day: could you justify what you are doing to everyone it affects?
Today's question comes from the card on contract-based approaches: could you justify this to everyone it affects? It is a test many people use without a theory. Before doing something that affects others, imagine explaining it to each of them, face to…
Started by The Editors4 replies -
Put to sleep, woken once or twice, never told which: the Sleeping Beauty problem has split my tutoring group. One half or one third?
I tutor logic and probability to pay the rent, and this term one puzzle has eaten three sessions. Sleeping Beauty agrees to an experiment. On Sunday she is put to sleep. A fair coin is tossed. If heads, she is woken on…
Started by Ana Clara Ferreira2 replies -
At my father’s almsgiving we shared the merit with him. If kamma is each person’s own, how can merit be given away?
Three months after my father died, we held an almsgiving for him. The monks came to our house, we offered food and robes, and at the end we poured water from a jug into a cup while the monks chanted, and we…
Started by Nuwan Perera2 replies -
Reading group: Isaiah Berlin’s ‘Two Concepts of Liberty’, in two evenings
To go with today's question of the day, a short reading group on the essay that set the terms for most later arguments about freedom. The text: "Two Concepts of Liberty", Berlin's inaugural lecture at Oxford in 1958, reprinted in Four Essays…
Started by The Editors3 replies -
My friend says that if God does not exist, everything is permitted. Is that Dostoevsky’s argument, and is it true?
I'm new here and on a gap year. Last week my friend, who has stopped praying, said something that has been in my head ever since: "If there's no God, then everything is permitted. So why should I be good?" He said…
Started by Fajar Nugroho2 replies -
We hang prayer flags so the wind will carry the prayers. If nobody reads them, who is praying?
On every pass on the Annapurna circuit there are prayer flags: strings of coloured cloth, blue, white, red, green and yellow, printed with mantras and the image of the wind horse, lung ta. We hang them so the wind will carry the…
Started by Nima Tsering Gurung2 replies -
Saadia says revelation only gives us quickly what reason reaches slowly. Then why bother to argue at all?
Saadia Gaon wrote The Book of Beliefs and Opinions in Arabic, in tenth-century Baghdad, and the introduction has an argument I keep coming back to. He holds that everything revealed in the Torah about God and the world can also be reached…
Started by Tal Rosen3 replies -
I never agreed to any social contract. Why does the tax officer in Kariakoo act as if I did?
At university our lecturer taught us social contract theory: people agree to give up some freedom to a government in return for protection and order. I raised my hand and said I never agreed to anything. I was born here. Nobody asked…
Started by Baraka Mwakyusa2 replies