Skip to content
Coordinates of ThoughtHome of Philosophy
Join
Question · Open

When our game’s economy crashed, players blamed us as if we were gods. What does the maker of a world owe the people living in it?

Its coordinates: 6.25 Philosophy of Sport and Play · 6.27 Philosophy of Humour

Last month a bug in our online game let a few players duplicate gold. Within two days prices in the game's markets had gone mad, and players who had saved for months found their savings nearly worthless. We fixed the bug and rolled back some trades, but not all.

The forums were furious, and the language surprised me. Players wrote things like "you made this world, you let this happen", "why did you allow it?" and "you could have stopped it at any time". One long post was titled, half as a joke, "The problem of evil in our server".

I've been thinking about that title. We are not omnipotent or omniscient. But inside the game, compared to the players, we nearly are: we can see every transaction and change any rule.

So I'd like to ask philosophers who know the theology:

  • Do the makers of a world owe its inhabitants a fair world, or only a world that is interesting to live in?
  • Is "we gave players freedom, and some abused it" a good defence, or the same excuse theologians are accused of making?
  • And if we intervene every time something goes wrong, do we destroy what makes the world worth playing?
LikeAnswerSaveFollow2 answers

Join the conversation: members reply here, and joining is free. Reading is always free.

Join free to reply Sign in

2 answers

  1. Omar Ragab

    Contributor

    The theologians I read would notice something in your forum posts: the players assume that because you can intervene, you must. The Muʿtazila agreed with your players: a just creator owes his creatures what is best for them. The Ashʿarites said no creature has a claim on the creator at all.

    But you have something God, on any of those views, does not: you're accountable to the players, who pay you. So you owe them fairness as a contract. Whether you'd owe it without the subscription fee is the old question.

  2. Derek Hollis

    Fellow

    Chalmers takes your situation seriously in Reality+: if we can build worlds with inhabitants, then the ethics of creators stops being purely theological. His view, roughly, is that a simulator's moral duties to its inhabitants are real, and that the "free will defence" only works if the freedom is worth the harm.

    Your rollback is interesting. You intervened partly. That's the move theologians call "permitting some evils, not all", and your forum shows how hard it is to explain where the line was drawn.