Thinker · TH-0148
Ernest Sosa
Ernest Sosa is a Cuban-born American epistemologist who taught for many years at Brown University and later at Rutgers. He is a leading architect…
b. 1940 · Cárdenas (Cuba); Providence; New Brunswick, New Jersey
Traditions: Analytic
Ernest Sosa is a Cuban-born American epistemologist who taught for many years at Brown University and later at Rutgers. He is a leading architect of virtue epistemology, which treats knowledge as a kind of successful performance that is creditable to the knower's competence. In the dispute between internalists and externalists about justification, his work occupies an influential middle ground: reliable faculties do much of the work, but a reflective perspective on one's own reliability marks a higher grade of knowing.
Key ideas
- Knowledge is belief that is apt: accurate because it manifests the believer's epistemic competence.
- He distinguishes animal knowledge, which needs only reliable faculties, from reflective knowledge, which adds a perspective endorsing those faculties.
- Performances in general can be assessed as accurate, adroit and apt, and belief is one such performance.
- He defended a safety condition on knowledge as an alternative to sensitivity-based accounts.
Major works
- Knowledge in Perspective (1991)
- A Virtue Epistemology: Apt Belief and Reflective Knowledge (2007)
- Reflective Knowledge (2009)
- Judgment and Agency (2015)
In the conversation
- Question Norman the clairvoyant is reliably right, yet most people say he doesn’t know. Why?
- Question My model was right for the wrong reason. Which answer to Gettier explains why that matters?
- Debate Reliabilism has a machine problem: reliable prediction is not knowledge
- Discussion A verdict that was right by accident: did the court know he was guilty?