Skip to content
Coordinates of ThoughtHome of Philosophy
Join

Book corner · Advanced

Philosophy of Language

Scott Soames · 2010 · Medium (150–350 pages)

4.0 from 2 reviews · 36 views

+ Add to my shelf

Be the first to put it on your shelf.

What it is

A concise and demanding survey of the philosophy of language in the analytic tradition, written for the Princeton Foundations of Contemporary Philosophy series. Soames traces how the study of meaning developed from Frege's distinction between sense and reference and Russell's theory of descriptions, through Tarski's theory of truth and Davidson's proposal that a theory of meaning is a theory of truth conditions, to the possible-worlds semantics of later logicians. He then discusses the revolution brought by Kripke's work on names and necessity and by theories of indexicals and direct reference, the debate about what propositions are, and the relation between what sentences mean and what speakers assert. Soames argues for his own views at several points, particularly on propositions and the semantics–pragmatics boundary, while presenting the history fairly.

Why read it

It explains in a short space how the main theories of meaning arose and where they now stand, by someone who shaped the debate.

Where to start

Read the opening chapters on Frege and Russell, then the chapter on Kripke and direct reference.

Reviews

  1. Derek Hollis

    I build formal-verification tools, so semantics as truth conditions is home territory. Soames's account of how Tarski's work was turned into a theory of meaning was the clearest I have read. The chapters on propositions are where he argues for his own view, and they are tougher going.

  2. Oskar Nyberg

    I teach this field and Soames is a reliable, compressed guide. It is very much the analytic story, Frege to Kripke and beyond; the Sanskrit grammarians I love are absent, and so are the Buddhist theories of meaning. For a graduate seminar it is excellent; for a beginner it is a cliff face.