Arguments
Philosophy’s structured arguments, from the cosmological argument to the Chinese room: find one by name or browse by question, subject, thinker, tradition or letter.
On this page
441 structured arguments. Each sets out the argument’s steps, the main objections and the replies, with the questions, thinkers and traditions it belongs to.
Find or filter the arguments
Matching arguments
4 arguments for Gilbert Harman.
-
Dogmatism paradox
Saul Kripke's puzzle that, if I know something, I seem entitled to dismiss all future evidence against it as misleading.
-
Harman's explanatory challenge to moral realism
Gilbert Harman's argument (1977) that moral facts, unlike physical facts, play no role in explaining our observations or what happens in the world, so we have no reason to believe in them.
-
Lottery paradox
The puzzle that in a large fair lottery it seems rational to believe of each ticket that it will lose, although one knows that some ticket will win, so that rational beliefs appear to form an inconsistent set.
-
Situationism (moral psychology)
The position, drawn from social psychology, that features of situations explain much more of people's behaviour than is usually supposed and robust character traits correspondingly less; a challenge to virtue ethics.