Skip to content
Coordinates of ThoughtHome of Philosophy
Join
Debate

Thesis

Levinas’s face of the Other can ground human rights better than self-ownership can

Its coordinates: 6.4.2 Rights and Liberty

Where it stands

Most theories of rights begin with the self: I own myself, I have interests, I make claims. Levinas begins somewhere else. In Totality and Infinity (1961) and Otherwise than Being (1974), the face of the other person comes before any theory and makes a demand on me. In interviews he summed up its first word as: you shall not kill.

In the essay "The Rights of Man and the Rights of the Other", collected in Outside the Subject, Levinas suggests that human rights are first the rights of the other person, which I am responsible for, before they are mine to claim.

I translate philosophy for a living and have spent months with his French. My thesis: this is a better foundation for rights than self-ownership. It explains why rights bind those who have power, why they don't depend on the right-holder's ability to assert them, and why we feel their pull most strongly before the most vulnerable.

Thesis: Levinas's face of the Other can ground human rights better than self-ownership can.

LikeReplySaveFollow7 replies

Join the conversation: members reply here, and joining is free. Reading is always free.

Join free to reply Sign in

7 replies

For the thesis 2

  1. Miriam Adler

    For Fellow

    For, and Levinas anticipated Tomasz. In Otherwise than Being he introduces the "third party": once there is another person besides the one before me, I must compare, weigh and judge. That's where justice, institutions and equal rights come in. Symmetry is built on asymmetry, not instead of it. The face is the source; the third party gives it a public shape.

    Helpful · 1
  2. Mateo Quispe

    For Fellow

    For. Dussel took Levinas into Latin America precisely to address Sana's objection. The excluded, the colonised and the poor, are outside the political community, and the face of the excluded Other is what calls the community to account. Without something like the face, Arendt's refugees have no claim on anyone except through a citizenship they've lost. The face is where the claim begins.

    Helpful · 1

Against the thesis 3

  1. Tomasz Szewczak

    Against Fellow

    Against. Rights need to be universal and symmetrical: everyone has them equally. Levinas's relation is asymmetrical, between me and this particular other, to whom I owe more than they owe me. You can't build a symmetrical system out of an asymmetrical foundation without bringing in something else. Miriam may say the third party supplies it. Then the work is being done by justice, not by the face.

    1. Claire Dubois

      Author’s response Fellow

      Tomasz, Miriam's point is the one I'd make. The third party doesn't abolish the asymmetry; it shapes it into law. And that, I think, is an advantage: it explains why the state must justify itself to the vulnerable, not the other way around. Self-ownership starts from the strong and asks what they may keep. Levinas starts from the weak and asks what is owed to them. I find the second the better starting point for rights.

      Helpful · 2
  2. Hamza Qureshi

    Against Fellow

    Against. Courts need rules that can be applied consistently, not infinite responsibility. A judge who felt infinitely responsible to every litigant couldn't decide anything. Hart's account of law as a system of rules seems much closer to how rights work in practice. Levinas may describe the moral source, but he doesn't give us anything a court can use. That gap matters.

    Helpful · 3
  3. Sana Rizvi

    Against Fellow

    Against. Arendt saw something Levinas doesn't address. In The Origins of Totalitarianism (1951) she argued that refugees stripped of citizenship found that their "human rights" meant nothing: what they lacked was "the right to have rights", membership in a political community. Faces were in front of everyone, and it didn't help. Rights need institutions before they need ethics. That is my objection.

    1. Claire Dubois

      Revision by the author Fellow

      Sana, I take Arendt's point seriously, and I've changed my mind on part of the thesis: rights need institutions to be effective. But Mateo's reply shows why the source still matters. The demand for those institutions, and for including those who are outside them, has to come from somewhere. I still think the face is a better source than self-ownership.

      Helpful · 2