Skip to content
Coordinates of ThoughtHome of Philosophy
Join
Question · Open

The Sufi poets call the lover a slave of the Beloved. Can giving up your will be the fullest kind of freedom?

Its coordinates: 6.1.1 Religious Experience

When I draw a motif slowly with the canting, I sometimes sing the old Sufi verses my aunt taught me. Many of them, in Malay and Javanese as well as in Persian, say the same paradoxical thing: the lover is the servant of the Beloved, and only in that service is she free.

Hamzah Fansuri, the Sufi poet of Sumatra, wrote of the seeker who must lose himself to find God. Rumi, whose Masnavi opens with the reed cut from the reed-bed and crying to go home, describes the self as something to be emptied, so that what moves us is no longer our own small will.

Everyone here today is talking about freedom: freedom from interference, freedom to choose, the power actually to act. In all of these, the free person is the one whose will is not blocked. The Sufi idea seems to turn this upside down. The highest state is the one in which you no longer want anything for yourself.

I can feel what the poets mean when I am deep in a pattern and stop deciding each line. But I also know how the language of surrender can be used to keep women, workers and students quiet.

So I would like to ask:
– Is surrender of the will a kind of freedom, or a beautiful name for its opposite?
– What is the difference between surrendering to God and surrendering to a person who claims to speak for God?

LikeAnswerSaveFollow3 answers

Join the conversation: members reply here, and joining is free. Reading is always free.

Join free to reply Sign in

3 answers

  1. Aoife Kilbride

    Contributor

    Christianity has the same paradox in its liturgy. An old Anglican prayer calls God the one "whose service is perfect freedom", and Augustine's "love, and do what you will" says something similar from the other side: once the will is formed by love, following it is no longer self-assertion.

    On your second question, the tradition's answer is that any person who claims your surrender to God for himself has stolen something. Surrender to God is meant to free you from exactly those people.

  2. Claire Dubois

    Fellow

    Isaiah Berlin, whose essay is today's reading group, has a name for one version of this: the retreat to the inner citadel. If I cannot get what I want, I can stop wanting it, and call myself free. He thought this was a real kind of freedom and also a dangerous one, because a ruler can always tell his subjects to want less.

    Your batik example seems different to me, though. When you stop deciding each line, you have not given up wanting. You have become so good that wanting and doing coincide. That's mastery, not retreat.

  3. Elif Yıldız

    Contributor

    My grandmother read me Yunus Emre, who keeps saying that he is nothing and that this nothing is where God lives. As a child I found it sad. Now I think he was describing what psychologists call losing yourself in an activity, but aimed at God instead of at a task.

    The test for me is what happens afterwards. If you come back more yourself, kinder and braver, the surrender freed you. If you come back smaller and more afraid, someone else took what you gave.