Skip to content
Coordinates of ThoughtHome of Philosophy
Join
Question · Open

The Bauls sing of the “Man of the Heart” who lives inside the body. Is he God, the true self, or both?

Its coordinates: 6.1.1 Religious Experience

My father sang Baul songs, and I still hum them on night shifts. The Bauls of Bengal refused the temple and the mosque. They said the one they seek, the moner manush, the Man of the Heart, lives in the body itself.

Lalon, the most famous of them, sang about an unknown bird that comes and goes inside the cage of the body. If he could catch it, he would put the shackles of his mind on its feet. But he can't: the bird is so close, and he never sees it.

On the ward I see women in labour at the edge of what a body can bear, and sometimes I think I understand the song. But I would like to know what philosophers make of it.

  • Is the Man of the Heart God, living in each person?
  • Is he the person's own true self, which we fail to know?
  • Or is the whole point that there is no difference between the two?

I know the Upanishads say the self is Brahman, and I have heard Sufis quote a saying, "whoever knows himself knows his Lord." Are the Bauls saying the same thing, or something of their own?

LikeAnswerSaveFollow2 answers

Join the conversation: members reply here, and joining is free. Reading is always free.

Join free to reply Sign in

2 answers

  1. Kavya Menon

    Contributor

    Tagore loved these songs, and in The Religion of Man he quotes a Baul song by Gagan Harkara, a village postman: where shall I find him, the Man of my Heart? Tagore took the Man of the Heart as his own name for the divine in humanity: neither a God outside us nor just ourselves, but what in us reaches beyond us.

    I don't think the Bauls would accept being turned into Upanishads. They are not saying "the self is Brahman" as a doctrine. They are saying: stop looking elsewhere. The emphasis is on the search, and on the body as the place of it.

  2. Ratna Wulandari

    Contributor

    The saying you heard, "whoever knows himself knows his Lord", is quoted everywhere in Sufi writing, though hadith scholars say it is not a sound saying of the Prophet. The Sufis kept it anyway, and read it in two ways. Some take it as identity. Many take it as a mirror: you know your Lord by knowing your own poverty and need, which shows you what you are not.

    Your bird that is close but never seen fits the second reading better, I think. If the self simply were God, why would the bird be so hard to catch?