Skip to content
Coordinates of ThoughtHome of Philosophy
Join

Book corner · Advanced

Art and Its Objects

Richard Wollheim · 1968

4.5 from 2 reviews · 39 views

+ Add to my shelf

Be the first to put it on your shelf.

What it is

Wollheim approaches the question 'What is art?' by asking what kind of thing a work of art is. He tests the hypothesis that works of art are physical objects, which seems plausible for paintings and sculptures but fails for novels and pieces of music, which can exist in many copies and performances. He develops the idea that many works are types with tokens, discusses how art expresses emotion and how we see representations in pictures, and examines the role of the artist's intention and the spectator's response. He argues that art should be understood as, in Wittgenstein's phrase, a form of life, bound up with the practices and institutions in which it is made and received. The second edition of 1980 adds six supplementary essays, including one on 'seeing-in', Wollheim's influential account of pictorial representation, and one criticising the institutional theory of art.

Why read it

It is a classic of analytic aesthetics written by someone who was also a serious art critic, and it shows why defining art is harder than it looks.

Where to start

Read the opening sections on the physical-object hypothesis, then the supplementary essay on seeing-as and seeing-in.

Reviews

  1. Chiara Bellandi

    The physical-object hypothesis is my working life. When I fill a loss in a panel, am I altering the work or just the object? Wollheim does not answer that for me, but he gives the best framework I have found for asking it. The numbered sections are dense; I read it slowly over a winter.

  2. Agnieszka Malinowska

    I came via Ingarden, who asked what a musical work is if it is not any one performance. Wollheim's type and token account is a cleaner answer and I mostly accept it, though I think it handles improvised and liturgical music less well. Hard, worthwhile, and written by someone who clearly loved looking at pictures.