Dussel's argument from exteriority
On this page
Enrique Dussel's argument in Philosophy of Liberation (1977) that the philosophy of the centre thinks only a totality that justifies domination, that the oppressed Other stands outside every such totality and calls it to justice, and that philosophy must therefore begin from that exteriority.
The argument at a glance
A guide to the entry below, quoting its own words. Skip to the full entry and its sources.
- Question
- From where should philosophy begin, if the philosophy that claims universality has served as the theory of a dominating order? The method associated with the answer is described in the entry Analectics (analéctica); this entry reconstructs the argument that leads to it in Enrique Dussel's Filosofía de la liberación (1977), cited here by section from the English translation by Aquilina Martinez and Christine Morkovsky (Philosophy of Liberation, Orbis, 1985).
- Reasons , Numbered as set out in the entry; the entry does not say who numbered the steps
-
- The ontology of the centre thinks Being as the foundation of a totality, the system that unifies all beings, and identifies that order with the boundaries of the dominant civilisation; Being is "the very foundation of the system, the totality of the sense of a culture" (1.1.4.1; compare 2.2.5.1), and Dussel reads Parmenides' 'Being is; non-Being is not' as making Being extend as far as the frontiers of Hellenism (1.1.5.1). Hence his verdict: "Classic philosophy of all ages is the theoretical consummation of the practical oppression of peripheries" (1.1.4.3).
- A person cannot be fully comprehended as a moment of such a system: "A person is not something, but someone" (2.4.2.2).
- Exteriority is the sphere from which other persons reveal themselves as free and not conditioned by one's own system (2.4.2.3); the Other is the alterity of all possible systems, beyond the totality of the same (2.4.4.1).
- Historically the Other appears as the poor and oppressed, outside the system, whose suffering faces challenge it (2.4.4.2) and, in Dussel's etymology, "provoke justice", calling from ahead (2.4.4.3).
- The movement of the totality as such is dialectical (2.2.8.2), so thought that starts within it develops it from identity to difference and reproduces its exclusions; to hear the Other requires a logic of exteriority that is "analectical (5.3)" and not merely dialectical (2.4.3.5), a metaphysics rather than an ontology (1.2.6.3).
- Therefore: the philosophy of liberation must start outside the system: "Our thought sets out from non-Being, nothingness, otherness, exteriority, the mystery of no-sense" (1.2.6.2).
- Intended conclusion
- The starting point of a philosophy that is not an ideology of domination is the interpellation of those excluded by the prevailing order; philosophy is first an ethical and political response to the Other, and only then a theory of what is. Michael Barber's study, Ethical Hermeneutics (Fordham University Press, 1997), stresses the source and the departure: Dussel takes from Emmanuel Levinas the Other who is not a term in a formal relation, but transposes it to Latin America, gives it historical content and develops the analectical method and a critique of false universals.
Objections and replies
- Objections , Raised by other thinkers and critics, as reported
-
- Irrationalism. Barber reports that the main criticisms, from Ofelia Schutte and Horacio Cerutti Guldberg, converge on the charge that Dussel advances a first philosophy without rational demonstration, places it above the sciences, fosters uncritical heteronomy before the Other, and supports Perón's populism, which they called fascist.
- No authentic starting point. Eduardo Mendieta's Stanford Encyclopedia entry describes the analectical current as holding that the authentic people is always outside the totality, and reports that the movement's historicist current rejects any absolute, unsoiled and authentic point of departure, while its problematising current rejects authenticity as a criterion; both strike directly at premise (6).
- The Other as woman. Mendieta reports Schutte's criticism of the 1980 treatment of woman as the Other of man as a machista ontologisation of Catholic, and more broadly Christian, understandings of sex and gender.
- Discourse ethics. Karl-Otto Apel, as Barber reports, judged Dussel's turn to Marx utopian and anachronistic and proposed that transcendental pragmatics could take over the tasks of the philosophy of liberation.
- Replies
-
Barber argues that the irrationalism charge overlooks Dussel's Levinasian roots, on which discourse begins because an Other has asked for an account, so that the Other's appeal precedes argument without abolishing it, and that Dussel could accept his critics' positive endorsement of rationality; to Apel he proposes a division of philosophical labour, with Levinas's notion of the third party as a bridge. He concedes that Dussel's sexual ethics showed inadequate attention to alterity. Dussel himself, in the epilogue to the 1994 edition reported by Mendieta, rejected and criticised his earlier views on gender; the revision Mendieta reports concerns those views, not the argument from exteriority as such. After his debates with Apel and Jürgen Habermas, Mendieta reports, Dussel moved towards a more dialectical philosophy of liberation that took the linguistic and pragmatic turn.
Coordinate 6.4Coordinate 3.2Coordinate 6.31Enrique DusselParmenidesEmmanuel LevinasOfelia SchutteHoracio Cerutti GuldbergJürgen HabermasSources and primary textsRead the full entry
What it means
Question. From where should philosophy begin, if the philosophy that claims universality has served as the theory of a dominating order? The method associated with the answer is described in the entry Analectics (analéctica); this entry reconstructs the argument that leads to it in Enrique Dussel's Filosofía de la liberación (1977), cited here by section from the English translation by Aquilina Martinez and Christine Morkovsky (Philosophy of Liberation, Orbis, 1985).
Structure. (1) The ontology of the centre thinks Being as the foundation of a totality, the system that unifies all beings, and identifies that order with the boundaries of the dominant civilisation; Being is "the very foundation of the system, the totality of the sense of a culture" (1.1.4.1; compare 2.2.5.1), and Dussel reads Parmenides' 'Being is; non-Being is not' as making Being extend as far as the frontiers of Hellenism (1.1.5.1). Hence his verdict: "Classic philosophy of all ages is the theoretical consummation of the practical oppression of peripheries" (1.1.4.3). (2) A person cannot be fully comprehended as a moment of such a system: "A person is not something, but someone" (2.4.2.2). (3) Exteriority is the sphere from which other persons reveal themselves as free and not conditioned by one's own system (2.4.2.3); the Other is the alterity of all possible systems, beyond the totality of the same (2.4.4.1). (4) Historically the Other appears as the poor and oppressed, outside the system, whose suffering faces challenge it (2.4.4.2) and, in Dussel's etymology, "provoke justice", calling from ahead (2.4.4.3). (5) The movement of the totality as such is dialectical (2.2.8.2), so thought that starts within it develops it from identity to difference and reproduces its exclusions; to hear the Other requires a logic of exteriority that is "analectical (5.3)" and not merely dialectical (2.4.3.5), a metaphysics rather than an ontology (1.2.6.3). Therefore (6) the philosophy of liberation must start outside the system: "Our thought sets out from non-Being, nothingness, otherness, exteriority, the mystery of no-sense" (1.2.6.2).
Intended conclusion. The starting point of a philosophy that is not an ideology of domination is the interpellation of those excluded by the prevailing order; philosophy is first an ethical and political response to the Other, and only then a theory of what is. Michael Barber's study, Ethical Hermeneutics (Fordham University Press, 1997), stresses the source and the departure: Dussel takes from Emmanuel Levinas the Other who is not a term in a formal relation, but transposes it to Latin America, gives it historical content and develops the analectical method and a critique of false universals.
Objections. (a) Irrationalism. Barber reports that the main criticisms, from Ofelia Schutte and Horacio Cerutti Guldberg, converge on the charge that Dussel advances a first philosophy without rational demonstration, places it above the sciences, fosters uncritical heteronomy before the Other, and supports Perón's populism, which they called fascist. (b) No authentic starting point. Eduardo Mendieta's Stanford Encyclopedia entry describes the analectical current as holding that the authentic people is always outside the totality, and reports that the movement's historicist current rejects any absolute, unsoiled and authentic point of departure, while its problematising current rejects authenticity as a criterion; both strike directly at premise (6). (c) The Other as woman. Mendieta reports Schutte's criticism of the 1980 treatment of woman as the Other of man as a machista ontologisation of Catholic, and more broadly Christian, understandings of sex and gender. (d) Discourse ethics. Karl-Otto Apel, as Barber reports, judged Dussel's turn to Marx utopian and anachronistic and proposed that transcendental pragmatics could take over the tasks of the philosophy of liberation.
Replies. Barber argues that the irrationalism charge overlooks Dussel's Levinasian roots, on which discourse begins because an Other has asked for an account, so that the Other's appeal precedes argument without abolishing it, and that Dussel could accept his critics' positive endorsement of rationality; to Apel he proposes a division of philosophical labour, with Levinas's notion of the third party as a bridge. He concedes that Dussel's sexual ethics showed inadequate attention to alterity. Dussel himself, in the epilogue to the 1994 edition reported by Mendieta, rejected and criticised his earlier views on gender; the revision Mendieta reports concerns those views, not the argument from exteriority as such. After his debates with Apel and Jürgen Habermas, Mendieta reports, Dussel moved towards a more dialectical philosophy of liberation that took the linguistic and pragmatic turn.
Key thinkers and texts. Enrique Dussel, Filosofía de la liberación (1977; on this site Philosophy of Liberation), chapters 1 and 2; Emmanuel Levinas's account of the Other as the source; Ofelia Schutte's critique (1993, as cited by Mendieta and Barber) and Horacio Cerutti Guldberg's; Michael D. Barber, Ethical Hermeneutics: Rationality in Enrique Dussel's Philosophy of Liberation (1997).
Coordinates. On this site it belongs to Coordinate 6.4 (Political Philosophy), since it concerns the standpoint from which an unjust order can be judged; it also bears on Coordinate 3.2 (Normative Ethics) and Coordinate 6.31 (Philosophy of Culture).
Current status. Mendieta suggests that the analectical label may already be anachronistic and that one should now speak of philosophies of liberation in the plural, and he reports that Dussel himself has argued that the philosophy of liberation contributed to and is part of the decolonial turn in Latin American philosophy. Whether exteriority can serve as a starting point without fixing the oppressed as a metaphysical given, the historicists' objection, remains the central point of dispute.
See also the glossary entries Analectics (analéctica), Face of the Other, Philosophy of liberation, Transmodernity, Decoloniality and Liberation theology.
The questions it belongs to
- 6.4 Political PhilosophyWhen is political power legitimate, and what may it rightly do?
- 3.2 Normative EthicsWhat should I look at to tell whether an act is right?
- 6.31 Philosophy of CultureCan you understand a culture from outside it?
Thinkers
Traditions
To read
- Cultural Identity and Social Liberation in Latin American Thought — Ofelia Schutte
- Difficult Freedom: Essays on Judaism (Difficile liberté) — Emmanuel Levinas
- Filosofía de la liberación latinoamericana — Horacio Cerutti Guldberg
Sources and further reading
- Enrique Dussel, Philosophy of Liberation, translated by Aquilina Martinez and Christine Morkovsky (Maryknoll, NY: Orbis, 1985), copy in the Enrique Dussel digital archive
- Eduardo Mendieta, 'Philosophy of Liberation', Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (first published 28 January 2016; substantive revision 7 October 2020)
- Michael D. Barber, Ethical Hermeneutics: Rationality in Enrique Dussel's Philosophy of Liberation (New York: Fordham University Press, 1997, per library catalogue records), copy in the Enrique Dussel digital archive
- PhilPapers, linked bibliography for Eduardo Mendieta's SEP entry 'Philosophy of Liberation' (translators listed as Aquila [sic] Martinez and Christine Morkovsky)
- Alexander V. Stehn, 'Latin American Philosophy', Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
- Library catalogue record (Texas A&M University Libraries): Michael D. Barber, Ethical hermeneutics: rationality in Enrique Dussel's Philosophy of liberation (Fordham University Press, 1997)
- Roberto S. Goizueta, review of Dussel, Philosophy of Liberation, trans. Aquilina Martinez and Christine Morkowsky [sic] (Orbis, 1985), Horizons 13, no. 1 (1986), pp. 186-187
Cite this page
Responsibility: Coordinates of Thought Editors. Each statement was drafted from the sources listed above and checked against them in a separate pass before publishing; this page is not peer-reviewed by outside specialists. Source-checked 14 November 2026. How to cite this site · How we write and check.
APA (7th edition)
Coordinates of Thought Editors. (2026, November 14). Dussel's argument from exteriority (Arguments). Coordinates of Thought. Retrieved [date accessed], from https://coordinatesofthought.com/arguments/dussels-argument-from-exteriority/
MLA (9th edition)
“Dussel's argument from exteriority (Arguments).” Coordinates of Thought, 14 Nov. 2026, coordinatesofthought.com/arguments/dussels-argument-from-exteriority/. Accessed [date accessed].
Chicago (17th edition)
Coordinates of Thought Editors. “Dussel's argument from exteriority (Arguments).” Coordinates of Thought. Source-checked November 14, 2026. https://coordinatesofthought.com/arguments/dussels-argument-from-exteriority/.
BibTeX
@misc{cot-glossary-dussels-argument-from-exteriority-2026,
author = {{Coordinates of Thought Editors}},
title = {Dussel's argument from exteriority (Arguments)},
howpublished = {Coordinates of Thought},
year = {2026},
month = nov,
url = {https://coordinatesofthought.com/arguments/dussels-argument-from-exteriority/},
note = {Source-checked 14 November 2026}
}
RIS
TY - ELEC AU - Coordinates of Thought Editors TI - Dussel's argument from exteriority (Arguments) T2 - Coordinates of Thought PB - Coordinates of Thought PY - 2026 DA - 2026/11/14 UR - https://coordinatesofthought.com/arguments/dussels-argument-from-exteriority/ LA - en ER -
For reference managers (Zotero, Mendeley, EndNote): BibTeX file · RIS file