Skip to content
Coordinates of ThoughtHome of Philosophy
Join

Book corner · Philosophy · Beginner

What Is This Thing Called Science?

Alan Chalmers · 1976 · Medium (150–350 pages)

4.5 from 2 reviews

+ Add to my shelf

Be the first to put it on your shelf.

What it is

A widely used introduction to the philosophy of science. Chalmers begins with the common view that science is derived from the facts of observation by induction, and shows its problems: observation is shaped by theory and prior knowledge, and no amount of observation logically proves a general law. He then examines Popper's falsificationism, Kuhn's account of paradigms and scientific revolutions, Lakatos's methodology of research programmes, and Feyerabend's attack on method. Later editions add chapters on Bayesian approaches, the new experimentalism, laws of nature, and the debate between scientific realism and anti-realism. Each view is set out clearly and tested against episodes from the history of science, especially Galileo and early modern physics. Chalmers draws his own conclusions about what is defensible in each position.

Why read it

It is the clearest short account of how philosophers have tried to say what makes science scientific, and why it is harder than it looks.

Where to start

Read the opening chapters on observation and induction, then the chapters on Popper and Kuhn.

Reviews

  1. Lars Eriksen

    Clear and fair, and good on the problems with naive inductivism. As someone who builds instruments for experiments, I found the treatment of experiment in later editions more convincing than the older chapters on method, which still assume a theory-first picture. A good book to give students who think science is just collecting data.

  2. Emeka Anyaoha

    My physics degree never asked what makes physics a science. This book did, in the first week of my reading it, and I have been asking ever since. The chapter on Kuhn finally made sense of why my lecturers spoke of 'paradigms' as if it were obvious. I now use the Galileo examples in my tutoring.