Skip to content
Coordinates of ThoughtHome of Philosophy
Join

Book corner · Intermediate

The Kuzari

Kitāb al-ḥujja wa-l-dalīl fī naṣr al-dīn al-dhalīl (The Book of Refutation and Proof on Behalf of the Despised Religion)

Judah Halevi · c. 1140 · Medium (150–350 pages)

4.5 from 2 reviews · 36 views

+ Add to my shelf

Be the first to put it on your shelf.

What it is

A dialogue in five parts written in Judaeo-Arabic by the poet and philosopher Judah Halevi, built on the reported conversion of the king of the Khazars to Judaism. The king has dreamt that his intentions please God but his actions do not, and he questions in turn a philosopher, a Christian and a Muslim before inviting a rabbi. The philosopher offers a God who does not know individuals and a path of intellectual perfection in which it hardly matters how one worships, which leaves the king unsatisfied. The rabbi grounds his faith not in proofs but in history: the public revelation at Sinai, witnessed by a whole people and transmitted since. Later parts discuss the special relation of Israel and the land of Israel to the divine, the Hebrew language, prayer and law, and finally criticise Aristotelian philosophy and the theology of the mutakallimūn. It was translated into Hebrew in 1167.

Why read it

It is the classic Jewish argument for grounding faith in historical experience rather than philosophical proof, and its critique of the philosophers' God is as sharp as al-Ghazālī's.

Where to start

Read Part I, from the king's dream through the rabbi's opening argument, which contains the core of the book.

Original text in the public domain; free translations exist online

Reviews

  1. Tal Rosen

    I translate between Hebrew and Arabic for a living, and Halevi wrote this in Arabic in Hebrew letters and his poems in Hebrew, so I think of him as my patron saint. The argument from public revelation in Part I is cleverer than its critics allow. The claims about Israel's unique nature in Part II are what my study partners find hardest, and they rightly argue over them.

  2. Rabbi Eliana Gutman

    I teach Part I to adults who think Judaism needs philosophical proofs to be respectable. Halevi's king has already met the philosopher and found him uninterested in how you pray. That opening is a wonderful provocation. I part company with Halevi on how he describes other peoples, and I tell my class so.