Skip to content
Coordinates of ThoughtHome of Philosophy
Join

Book corner · Philosophy · Advanced

The Book of Metaphysical Penetrations

Kitāb al-Mashāʿir (كتاب المشاعر)

Mulla Sadra · 17th century · Short (under 150 pages)

4.5 from 2 reviews

+ Add to my shelf

Be the first to put it on your shelf.

What it is

A short Arabic treatise in which Mulla Sadra sets out the core of his metaphysics of existence, more compactly than in his vast Four Journeys. He argues that existence (wujud) is the most evident of all things yet cannot be defined, and that it, rather than quiddity or essence (mahiyya), is what is fundamentally real; quiddities are the limits of existence as the mind grasps them. Against thinkers in the tradition of Suhrawardi who treated existence as merely a mental notion, he argues that existence is a single reality that comes in degrees of intensity and perfection, from the weakest beings up to God as pure, unlimited existence. The treatise moves from these principles to questions about knowledge and the relation between God and the world.

Why read it

It is the most accessible way into the thought of one of the major philosophers of the Islamic world, whose 'primacy of existence' remains a living debate in Iran and beyond.

Where to start

Look for a bilingual or annotated edition, since the work appears under several English titles and needs notes on its technical vocabulary.

Reviews

  1. Reza Tehrani

    As an architect I think in gradations of light, and Sadra's idea that existence is one reality with degrees of intensity makes intuitive sense to me in a way Aristotle's categories never did. The treatise is short but each paragraph is dense. I read it with a teacher in Shiraz, and I would not have managed alone.

  2. Layla Sfeir

    A good entry point because it is compact, unlike the Four Journeys. Readers coming from Ibn Sina should notice how Sadra reworks the distinction between existence and essence that Ibn Sina made famous. Bring patience and a glossary; the terminology is unforgiving.