Salazar Bondy's argument from dependency to inauthenticity
On this page
Augusto Salazar Bondy's argument in ¿Existe una filosofía de nuestra América? (1968) that a culture formed under dependence and domination produces imitative, inauthentic philosophy, so that authentic Latin American philosophy awaits a transformation of the conditions that produce dependence; Leopoldo Zea's circumstantialist reply is its principal objection.
The argument at a glance
A guide to the entry below, quoting its own words. Skip to the full entry and its sources.
- Question
- Can a society that lives in economic and cultural dependence produce an authentic philosophy of its own? The general controversy over the existence and authenticity of Latin American philosophy, with its four main positions, is surveyed in the entry Latin American philosophy authenticity debate. This entry follows one argument within it: the case made by the Peruvian philosopher Augusto Salazar Bondy in ¿Existe una filosofía de nuestra América? (1968; on this site Is There a Philosophy in Our America?).
- Reasons , Reconstruction by the scholar named in the entry
-
Drawing on the Stanford Encyclopedia entries by Eduardo Mendieta and Susana Nuccetelli, Alexander Stehn's Internet Encyclopedia entry and Alexandre Queiroz's study of the 1968-69 debate, the reasoning runs as follows.
- A philosophy is authentic when, like any cultural product, it has integrity and is free of falsity or pretence (Nuccetelli, citing the 1968 book, pp. 100-101).
- Ideas are conditioned by the social base that sustains them (Queiroz).
- Spanish and Portuguese America has lived, in Mendieta's summary of the premise, under "mental colonialism, intellectual subordination, and philosophical dependence", bound up, in Stehn's account, with economic and cultural domination.
- The culture of a dominated people is itself a culture of domination, a defective culture in which imitative works are mistaken for authentic philosophy (Queiroz; Stehn).
- The historical record fits this: Latin American philosophy has been the thought of an elite (Nuccetelli, citing a 1969 text, p. 241), receiving European currents such as the Enlightenment, Romanticism and positivism late and out of place, like a transplanted tree in Salazar Bondy's image as Queiroz reports it.
- Therefore: there is as yet no rigorous and authentic Latin American philosophy; and
- since the defect lies in the conditions and not in individual talent, authenticity requires liberation from economic domination and cultural dependence, a decisive transformation of society (Stehn; Queiroz). (the entry continues below)
- Intended conclusion
- The question of Latin American philosophy is not settled by finding more original authors or a distinctive subject matter. It is a question about domination, and a genuinely authentic philosophy is a task for the future, bound up with liberation. Stehn stresses that for Salazar Bondy the problem is not that thought in the region lacks contact with concrete reality, but that the reality it expresses is itself alienated and divided.
Objections and replies
- Objections , Raised by other thinkers and critics, as reported
-
- Zea's circumstantialist reply. Leopoldo Zea answered in La filosofía americana como filosofía sin más (1969). Queiroz reports three moves: to ask whether there is a Latin American philosophy is already to philosophise from one's own problems; what is inauthentic is not philosophy produced under underdevelopment but philosophy that forms an idea of the human that denies the humanity of others; and ideas are not simply subordinate to economic structure but can themselves drive transformation. Behind the reply stands Zea's earlier argument, reconstructed by Nuccetelli, that every philosophical work shows the circumstance of its production and is in that sense authentic. Nuccetelli judges that this argument hinges on its first premise, a very strong claim, and reports Jorge Gracia's objection that there is an irresolvable problem in specifying what distinguishes a Latin American cultural circumstance from others.
- Ad hominem objections. Nuccetelli reports objections along these lines from Gracia (2003) and Guillermo Hurtado (2007): the critical theorist usually belongs to the elite whose thought, by the theory's own lights, cannot be authentic, and works with borrowed European traditions that, on the same view, cannot generate authentic Latin American philosophy.
- Counterexample. Nuccetelli offers the ethics of Bartolomé de las Casas as original and authentic although developed under extreme dependence, and calls reductionist at best the claim that cultural dependence and economic underdevelopment always determine a philosophy's shortcomings.
- Residual Eurocentrism. Queiroz argues that Salazar Bondy's analytical parameters remained tied to European thought, so that he looked at America through European eyes (p. 331), and that his base-and-superstructure reading neglects the internal dynamics of ideas (p. 328).
- Replies
-
Stehn reports that Salazar Bondy rejected Zea's position as ungrounded idealism: a change of standpoint cannot make thought authentic while the material conditions of dependence remain. Stehn's exposition shows why: the trouble is not that the region's philosophy fails to be rooted in concrete reality but that it is rooted in an alienated and divided socioeconomic reality, so being situated in one's circumstance does not by itself make a philosophy authentic. Nuccetelli records no reply from Salazar Bondy or his defenders to the self-defeat objections or the Las Casas counterexample. Mendieta dates the question's modern form to the debate begun by Salazar Bondy and Zea, records that Salazar Bondy gave a paper at the third jornada of the philosophy of liberation in 1973, and reports Horacio Cerutti Guldberg's view that he should be counted as contributing to that movement's problematising current.
Coordinate 6.31Coordinate 6.6Augusto Salazar BondyLeopoldo ZeaBartolomé de las CasasJosé Ortega y GassetJosé GaosFrantz FanonArturo Andrés RoigHoracio Cerutti GuldbergSources and primary textsRead the full entry
What it means
Question. Can a society that lives in economic and cultural dependence produce an authentic philosophy of its own? The general controversy over the existence and authenticity of Latin American philosophy, with its four main positions, is surveyed in the entry Latin American philosophy authenticity debate. This entry follows one argument within it: the case made by the Peruvian philosopher Augusto Salazar Bondy in ¿Existe una filosofía de nuestra América? (1968; on this site Is There a Philosophy in Our America?).
Structure. Drawing on the Stanford Encyclopedia entries by Eduardo Mendieta and Susana Nuccetelli, Alexander Stehn's Internet Encyclopedia entry and Alexandre Queiroz's study of the 1968-69 debate, the reasoning runs as follows. (1) A philosophy is authentic when, like any cultural product, it has integrity and is free of falsity or pretence (Nuccetelli, citing the 1968 book, pp. 100-101). (2) Ideas are conditioned by the social base that sustains them (Queiroz). (3) Spanish and Portuguese America has lived, in Mendieta's summary of the premise, under "mental colonialism, intellectual subordination, and philosophical dependence", bound up, in Stehn's account, with economic and cultural domination. (4) The culture of a dominated people is itself a culture of domination, a defective culture in which imitative works are mistaken for authentic philosophy (Queiroz; Stehn). (5) The historical record fits this: Latin American philosophy has been the thought of an elite (Nuccetelli, citing a 1969 text, p. 241), receiving European currents such as the Enlightenment, Romanticism and positivism late and out of place, like a transplanted tree in Salazar Bondy's image as Queiroz reports it. Therefore (6) there is as yet no rigorous and authentic Latin American philosophy; and (7) since the defect lies in the conditions and not in individual talent, authenticity requires liberation from economic domination and cultural dependence, a decisive transformation of society (Stehn; Queiroz). Stehn adds a corollary: the philosophy of the dominant centres is itself inauthentic in so far as it depends on domination of the Third World.
Intended conclusion. The question of Latin American philosophy is not settled by finding more original authors or a distinctive subject matter. It is a question about domination, and a genuinely authentic philosophy is a task for the future, bound up with liberation. Stehn stresses that for Salazar Bondy the problem is not that thought in the region lacks contact with concrete reality, but that the reality it expresses is itself alienated and divided.
Objections. (a) Zea's circumstantialist reply. Leopoldo Zea answered in La filosofía americana como filosofía sin más (1969). Queiroz reports three moves: to ask whether there is a Latin American philosophy is already to philosophise from one's own problems; what is inauthentic is not philosophy produced under underdevelopment but philosophy that forms an idea of the human that denies the humanity of others; and ideas are not simply subordinate to economic structure but can themselves drive transformation. Behind the reply stands Zea's earlier argument, reconstructed by Nuccetelli, that every philosophical work shows the circumstance of its production and is in that sense authentic. Nuccetelli judges that this argument hinges on its first premise, a very strong claim, and reports Jorge Gracia's objection that there is an irresolvable problem in specifying what distinguishes a Latin American cultural circumstance from others. (b) Ad hominem objections. Nuccetelli reports objections along these lines from Gracia (2003) and Guillermo Hurtado (2007): the critical theorist usually belongs to the elite whose thought, by the theory's own lights, cannot be authentic, and works with borrowed European traditions that, on the same view, cannot generate authentic Latin American philosophy. (c) Counterexample. Nuccetelli offers the ethics of Bartolomé de las Casas as original and authentic although developed under extreme dependence, and calls reductionist at best the claim that cultural dependence and economic underdevelopment always determine a philosophy's shortcomings. (d) Residual Eurocentrism. Queiroz argues that Salazar Bondy's analytical parameters remained tied to European thought, so that he looked at America through European eyes (p. 331), and that his base-and-superstructure reading neglects the internal dynamics of ideas (p. 328).
Replies. Stehn reports that Salazar Bondy rejected Zea's position as ungrounded idealism: a change of standpoint cannot make thought authentic while the material conditions of dependence remain. Stehn's exposition shows why: the trouble is not that the region's philosophy fails to be rooted in concrete reality but that it is rooted in an alienated and divided socioeconomic reality, so being situated in one's circumstance does not by itself make a philosophy authentic. Nuccetelli records no reply from Salazar Bondy or his defenders to the self-defeat objections or the Las Casas counterexample. Mendieta dates the question's modern form to the debate begun by Salazar Bondy and Zea, records that Salazar Bondy gave a paper at the third jornada of the philosophy of liberation in 1973, and reports Horacio Cerutti Guldberg's view that he should be counted as contributing to that movement's problematising current.
Key thinkers and texts. Augusto Salazar Bondy, ¿Existe una filosofía de nuestra América? (1968); Leopoldo Zea, La filosofía americana como filosofía sin más (1969), drawing, as Queiroz notes, on the historicism of José Ortega y Gasset and José Gaos and on Frantz Fanon; Arturo Andrés Roig, who in Nuccetelli's report called the work of Alejandro Deustua a prime example of the uprooting and alienation that Salazar Bondy denounced.
Coordinates. On this site it belongs to Coordinate 6.31 (Philosophy of Culture) and Coordinate 6.6 (Philosophy of History).
Current status. Nuccetelli concludes that, together with the counterexample, the objections render the critical theory implausible; at the same time she reports recent proposals that again tie the identity of Latin American philosophy to social conditions, Silva Grant's (2015), which she calls reductionist, and Orosco's (2016), which has reductionist connotations, together with Millán Brusslan's (2015) objection to Grant's as too exclusionary, and she offers her own applied-philosophy account, requiring sufficiently original arguments or methods and sensitivity to a Latin American context, as a middle way. Mendieta's observation that the subsequent movement is better described as philosophies of liberation, in the plural, shows how far the argument's programme was taken up and transformed. Whether dependence explains the character of a philosophy, rather than merely accompanying it, remains the disputed premise.
See also the glossary entries Latin American philosophy authenticity debate, Circumstantialism (circunstancialismo), Philosophy of liberation, Philosophical normalisation (normalidad filosófica), Coloniality of power and Ethnophilosophy.
The questions it belongs to
- 6.31 Philosophy of CultureCan you understand a culture from outside it?
- 6.6 Philosophy of HistoryIs history going anywhere?
Thinkers
- Augusto Salazar Bondy
- Leopoldo Zea
- Bartolomé de las Casas
- José Ortega y Gasset
- José Gaos
- Frantz Fanon
- Arturo Andrés Roig
- Horacio Cerutti Guldberg
Traditions
To read
- A Short Account of the Destruction of the Indies — Bartolomé de las Casas
- Black Skin, White Masks — Frantz Fanon
- Filosofía de la liberación latinoamericana — Horacio Cerutti Guldberg
Sources and further reading
- Eduardo Mendieta, 'Philosophy of Liberation', Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (first published 28 January 2016; substantive revision 7 October 2020)
- Susana Nuccetelli, 'Latin American Philosophy: Metaphilosophical Foundations', Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (first published 2 July 2013; substantive revision 27 October 2025)
- Alexander V. Stehn, 'Latin American Philosophy', Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
- Alexandre Queiroz, 'O Pensamento latino-americano nos anos 1960 e 1970: Debates, ideias, conceitos', Revista Eletrônica da ANPHLAC 24 (January-June 2018), pp. 324-353
Cite this page
Responsibility: Coordinates of Thought Editors. Each statement was drafted from the sources listed above and checked against them in a separate pass before publishing; this page is not peer-reviewed by outside specialists. Source-checked 14 November 2026. How to cite this site · How we write and check.
APA (7th edition)
Coordinates of Thought Editors. (2026, November 14). Salazar Bondy's argument from dependency to inauthenticity (Arguments). Coordinates of Thought. Retrieved [date accessed], from https://coordinatesofthought.com/arguments/salazar-bondys-argument-from-dependency-to-inauthenticity/
MLA (9th edition)
“Salazar Bondy's argument from dependency to inauthenticity (Arguments).” Coordinates of Thought, 14 Nov. 2026, coordinatesofthought.com/arguments/salazar-bondys-argument-from-dependency-to-inauthenticity/. Accessed [date accessed].
Chicago (17th edition)
Coordinates of Thought Editors. “Salazar Bondy's argument from dependency to inauthenticity (Arguments).” Coordinates of Thought. Source-checked November 14, 2026. https://coordinatesofthought.com/arguments/salazar-bondys-argument-from-dependency-to-inauthenticity/.
BibTeX
@misc{cot-glossary-salazar-bondys-argument-from-dependency-to-inauthenticity-2026,
author = {{Coordinates of Thought Editors}},
title = {Salazar Bondy's argument from dependency to inauthenticity (Arguments)},
howpublished = {Coordinates of Thought},
year = {2026},
month = nov,
url = {https://coordinatesofthought.com/arguments/salazar-bondys-argument-from-dependency-to-inauthenticity/},
note = {Source-checked 14 November 2026}
}
RIS
TY - ELEC AU - Coordinates of Thought Editors TI - Salazar Bondy's argument from dependency to inauthenticity (Arguments) T2 - Coordinates of Thought PB - Coordinates of Thought PY - 2026 DA - 2026/11/14 UR - https://coordinatesofthought.com/arguments/salazar-bondys-argument-from-dependency-to-inauthenticity/ LA - en ER -
For reference managers (Zotero, Mendeley, EndNote): BibTeX file · RIS file