Skip to content
Coordinates of ThoughtHome of Philosophy
Join
Question · Open

A treaty signed by our great-great-grandparents still shapes our lives. Can a promise bind people who weren’t born when it was made?

Its coordinates: 6.6 Philosophy of History

At our kura we teach the children about Te Tiriti o Waitangi, signed in 1840 by many Māori rangatira and representatives of the British Crown. The children learn that there was an English text and a Māori text, and that they did not say the same thing, and that much of the history since has been an argument about which promise was made.

My students ask a simpler question, the kind only children ask. "We didn't sign it. The people who signed it are dead. Why does it still count?"

I find this a deep question, and it cuts both ways. If promises can't bind people who weren't born, then the Crown's obligations lapsed long ago, and so did whatever the rangatira gave. If they can, then we are all living inside promises our ancestors made, and the question is how they bind us.

Hume thought that consent of the fathers can never bind the children. But many traditions, including ours, think obligations pass through whakapapa, through descent, as naturally as land and names.

  • Can an agreement bind future generations? Under what conditions?
  • Is a treaty between peoples different from a contract between persons?
  • And if the original promise was misunderstood on one side, what exactly binds?
LikeAnswerSaveFollow2 answers

Join the conversation: members reply here, and joining is free. Reading is always free.

Join free to reply Sign in

2 answers

  1. Thandeka Mokoena

    Fellow

    Your second question is the key. A treaty is made between peoples, which outlive the persons who sign. South Africa's constitution recognises that the state today is answerable for land taken by states long before it, not because today's officials made those decisions, but because the state is the same party, continuing.

    Children are right that they didn't sign. But they are members of a people that did, and peoples keep their word, or break it, across centuries.

  2. Baraka Mwakyusa

    Fellow

    My uncle would say the same as Thandeka, with Nyerere's words: the nation is a family, and a family's debts pass to its children. I used to think that was unfair. Then I realised I also inherited the family's land and name without signing for them.

    So maybe the honest answer to your students is: if you inherit the benefits of a promise, you inherit its obligations too. The hard part is when one side got the benefits and the other got the obligations.