Reading path · Beginner
Political philosophy: power, justice, freedom
Political philosophy asks when power is legitimate, what justice requires and how free people should be. This path starts with a lively modern introduction, then reads short classics before the longer works. Machiavelli and Hobbes put the question of power at its starkest. Mill, Ambedkar and Berlin argue about freedom, from individual liberty to the social conditions that make it real. Rawls closes the path with the most discussed modern theory of justice. Allow two to three months.
7 books, in order
-
Step 1: Justice: What’s the Right Thing to Do?
Michael J. Sandel · 2009
Sandel tests utilitarian, libertarian, Kantian, Rawlsian and Aristotelian answers against real controversies, so you meet the main positions before the classic texts.
- Where to start
- Read chapter 1, 'Doing the Right Thing', then chapters 5 and 6, on Kant and on Rawls.
- Time
- 2 weeks
- Difficulty
- Beginner
-
Step 2: The Prince
Niccolò Machiavelli · Written 1513; published 1532
Machiavelli advises a new ruler on gaining and holding a state, and asks whether a prince must sometimes act against conventional virtue. It is short and best read whole.
- Where to start
- If time is short, read chapters XV to XVIII, on praise and blame, liberality, cruelty and keeping faith, and chapter XXV on fortune.
- Time
- 2 evenings
- Difficulty
- Beginner
-
Step 3: On Liberty
John Stuart Mill · 1859
Mill argues that society may limit a person's liberty only to prevent harm to others, and makes a sustained case for freedom of thought and discussion.
- Where to start
- Read Chapter I, 'Introductory', and Chapter II, 'Of the Liberty of Thought and Discussion', which together form a complete argument.
- Time
- 3–4 evenings
- Difficulty
- Beginner
-
Step 4: Annihilation of Caste
B. R. Ambedkar · 1936
Ambedkar's undelivered speech of 1936 argues that caste denies liberty, equality and fraternity, and that political reform cannot succeed without social reform. It is short and best read whole.
- Where to start
- Read the speech whole, then 'A Reply to the Mahatma', Ambedkar's answer to Gandhi's review of it in Harijan.
- Time
- 2 evenings
- Difficulty
- Beginner
-
Step 5: Leviathan
Thomas Hobbes · 1651
Hobbes argues that without a common power people would live in a state of war, and that rational people would authorise a sovereign to escape it.
- Where to start
- Read chapters XIII to XV, on the natural condition of mankind and the laws of nature, then XVII on the commonwealth and XXI on the liberty of subjects.
- Time
- 2–3 weeks
- Difficulty
- Intermediate
-
Step 6: Four Essays on Liberty
Isaiah Berlin · 1969 (essays 1950–1959)
In 'Two Concepts of Liberty' Berlin separates freedom as non-interference from freedom as self-mastery, and warns how the second can be turned against individuals.
- Where to start
- Read 'Two Concepts of Liberty', then the Introduction Berlin wrote for this 1969 collection.
- Time
- 1 week
- Difficulty
- Intermediate
-
Step 7: A Theory of Justice
John Rawls · 1971 (revised edition 1999)
Rawls asks which principles free and equal people would choose behind a veil of ignorance about their own place in society. He argues for equal basic liberties and the difference principle.
- Where to start
- Read Part One, Chapters I to III ('Justice as Fairness', 'The Principles of Justice' and 'The Original Position'), before deciding how much of the rest you need.
- Time
- 3–4 weeks
- Difficulty
- Advanced
Then
- Question 6.4 Political Philosophy
- Question 6.4.1 Distributive Justice
- Question 6.4.2 Rights and Liberty
- Question 6.4.3 Sovereignty and the State
- Guide Fields of Philosophy: The Philosophy of Science, Mind, Religion, Law and Art